Translate Politics: Parliament in plain language.

Recent debates 8 latest debates

The Budget

The House debated the government’s Budget 2026, which members described as covering cost-of-living help, affordable housing, local infrastructure, investments in Canadian technology, immigration measures for worker shortages, and national defence. Liberal members argued the budget helps people with everyday costs, makes the caregiver tax credit fully refundable, targets low- and middle-income households through tax cuts, and builds long-term economic growth. Conservative members said the government’s spending plan is not working, pointing to about $85 billion in interest payments over five years, and called for lower taxes and tighter control of spending. The Bloc Québécois argued the budget falls short on health care transfers to Quebec and the provinces, and raised concerns about free park admission for foreign visitors while park jobs are cut. The NDP raised a funding gap between East Coast and West Coast ferry services, and members also exchanged views on the Alto high-speed rail project and its effect on farmland.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

48 statements

Michael Guglielmin, Vaughan—Woodbridge

Conservative
“I do not support this budget. The government claims to balance parts of it, but it uses fake accounting to hide billions in deficits and new debt. It spent almost all the extra money from high oil prices instead of lowering the deficit. Interest on our debt is rising fast and will soon cost more than our health-care transfers. The government needs to be honest about its real borrowing numbers and its spending on projects and housing.”
  • A repeated line

    “A former governor of the Bank of Canada.”

    Said 8 times by 8 members since April 28.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise and speak on the budget in the House of Commons today. Before I do, I would like to begin by giving a shout-out. I would first like to recognize the 10th anniversary of the Newman Global Initiative, founded a decade ago by Matthew Newman when he was just nine years old. This grassroots effort has grown from our community in Vaughan—Woodbridge into a dedicated network for young leaders. Over the past 10 years, the initiative has contributed over half a million dollars in community support and more than 5,700 hours of community service. From supporting educational and shelter projects internationally in India, Italy and Peru to local food security and youth programs here in Vaughan—Woodbridge, their work addresses real communities’ needs through direct action. This milestone is a tribute to our student volunteers, sponsors and supporters. I invite my colleagues to join me in congratulating the Newman Global Initiative on 10 years of service. The Liberals have titled this budget “Masters of our destiny”, but Canadians are not sold on this picture painting by the Liberal government. After reviewing the numbers and seeing what is inside this budget, I think the title masters of fiscal illusion might be a little more appropriate. Repeatedly we have heard from the Liberals that they are going to spend less and invest more, yet they committed almost all of their new fiscal room. They claim to balance operations using a definition that excludes $135 billion that would not qualify as capital investment in any internationally recognized accounting standards. Behind the headline, deficits sit at nearly $765 billion in new borrowing over the next five years. Members do not have to take my word for it. The Parliamentary Budget Officer delivered her verdict already earlier this week. She said, “This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more.” Canadians will pay real interest on this fiscal illusion. On Tuesday, the Parliamentary Budget Officer released a damning report on the fiscal track and sustainability of the Liberal budget. The PBO identified over $158 billion in new fiscal room that was largely granted to them due to an increase in oil prices over the recent months as a consequence of the war, which gave the Liberals an opportunity to demonstrate that they were actually prudent fiscal managers of our fiscal position. However, instead, what did they do? They went ahead and spent 96% of that newly found revenue on government programs. This, despite many economists urging the government to be cautious, saying that “those revenue increases should not be expected to continue.” According to the PBO, without the Liberals’ reckless spending measures, this year’s deficit could have fallen to around $43 billion, and in five years, it could have then fallen to $20 billion. They could have actually demonstrated here that we were on some sort of path to deficit recovery, but instead, they chose a path that leaves the deficit at $53 billion five years from now. Oxford economists labelled the Liberals’ budget as a “missed opportunity to lower the deficit and save” the future for the people of this country. This has not come as a surprise to Canadians at this point. We have become so accustomed over the past number of years to successive Liberal governments pushing the absolute limits of the public purse. The last few years have marked the worst fiscal stretch in Canadian history, with seven of the eight highest being the last seven consecutive years. The Liberals keep redefining their own fiscal anchors to fit their illusion to the Canadian taxpayer. Let us take, for example, that the Liberals dropped the declining debt-to-GDP ratio as their fiscal anchor before proceeding to take on historic levels of debt. The obscene federal debt is now projected to rise to $1.6 trillion in five years. Even the International Monetary Fund has recommended that the Liberal government restore its debt-to-GDP ratio as a primary fiscal anchor for Canada, saying that it would “strengthen discipline, transparency, and credibility” for future borrowing and the finances of this country. The PBO added, “Sustainability is commonly assessed by whether the debt-to-GDP ratio is stable or declining over the long term.” Those are her words. The Liberals instead point to their promise of balancing the operating budget, a term we are becoming more and more accustomed to hearing. That promise depends on what it calls “capital investments”. We hear them over and over again say that they are not spending, that they are making capital investments. That is why I use the phrase “fiscal illusion”, because that term, capital investment, and the way they are categorizing all of this really does reveal the real illusion that is at play with the budget. The PBO commented at the finance committee earlier this week that the Liberals list over $135 billion as so-called capital investments that would not qualify as capital investment under internationally recognized standards. If the $135 billion was appropriately treated as operating spending, the operating budget would remain in a deficit every single year for the next five-year forecast, despite the Liberal government’s claiming that it has met its fiscal anchor. That is the problem with the government’s marking its own homework. Its apparent success depends on a definition that it itself has chosen. I challenge the finance minister to table both calculations, so that Canadians can see exactly how much of this claimed balance comes from the government’s own made-up classifications. Canadians also deserve the full picture of federal borrowing. Over five years, the budget projects deficits totalling $289 billion. Its borrowing requirements total $765 billion. That is a gap of $476 billion. Neither of the government’s fiscal anchors places a ceiling on the cash borrowing requirements. When it comes to major projects like the Alto project, I had the transport minister at the finance committee. He seemed to suggest there was no ceiling to how much this project could cost. We hear the PBO say it could reach as high as $260 billion or more. It is a total waste of taxpayer dollars. Parliament should know who receives money, what return is expected and what happens if repayments fall short. Calling something an investment creates an obligation to demonstrate its value to taxpayers. Public debt charges are the fastest-growing expense for the government. This year, debt charges will cost $60.2 billion, reaching $85.5 billion in five years, consuming almost 14¢ of every dollar in federal revenue. If we remember, a previous governor of the Bank of Canada, David Dodge, came up with what is known as the “David Dodge Rule”, saying that governments should keep debt servicing costs below 10% of government revenues as a fiscal benchmark. This year, debt charges already exceed the Canada health transfer, the largest federal transfer to the provinces and territories. Every dollar committed to servicing debt is a dollar unavailable for another priority without additional taxes or even more borrowing. We are noticing a theme here. We see record levels of spending from the COVID era. One could make the case that during a time of crisis we needed elevated spending. None of that spending has been reduced. We see more and more layers added on, debt climbing higher and higher and debt-servicing costs growing even larger. The Prime Minister recently announced a loan of half a billion dollars to a Brazilian-run fund that provides compensation to governments that do not develop their rainforests. Why on earth would the Prime Minister believe that this is a good idea? Every dollar of that is a dollar that could have been used to help our own people, who are facing an ever-increasing need for help from the government. The government cannot demand fiscal discipline from Canadian families while treating scrutiny of its own decisions as a mere inconvenience. Housing is another primary indication of where we can judge the gap between promises and results. With housing starts declining, the government must explain how its plan to massively increase permanent residence will help the young Canadians I hear from every single day, who are struggling to afford homes and find a place to live. The government throws billions of dollars at housing while making the situation worse. Canadians deserve straight answers.

Michael Guglielmin, Vaughan—Woodbridge

Conservative
“The previous government left the country with strong finances and the strongest middle class in the G7. After ten years of this government, Canadians have too much debt. We have to borrow $765 billion and spend $85.5 billion on interest, which is more than we spend on health care transfers. This steals opportunities from our children. The government needs to control its spending.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 95 of 100

    Of this reply, 93% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I would remind the member opposite that prime minister Harper left the fiscal position of this country in fantastic shape. We had the strongest middle class in the G7. After 10 years of her current party holding government, we have the most indebted citizens in this country. We are sitting here at a time when we need to borrow $765 billion. We are going to be paying $85.5 billion in interest, more than we pay in health care transfer payments. We are robbing the next generation. We are robbing my kids, members’ kids and our grandchildren of future opportunity. We need fiscal discipline. I thought the Prime Minister was a financial wizard. What we are seeing here is not just more of the same, but worse fiscal discipline than we have ever seen before.

Michael Guglielmin, Vaughan—Woodbridge

Conservative
“We should develop our oil and gas quickly and build pipelines and refineries across the country. Other countries want our energy. The money we make from it would let us lower taxes for businesses and people, including in Quebec.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 41 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, what would really improve the fiscal position of Canadians all across this country, including in the great province of Quebec, would be if we developed our oil and gas industry as quickly as possible, built pipelines and refineries coast to coast, and took advantage of the geopolitical position we find ourselves in today, where people want more Canadian oil and gas. That would add to the government coffers so it could do things like real tax reform. It could make personal income tax and business taxes more competitive. It could even give people in Quebec a break on their taxes, because they are certainly overtaxed by the actions of the government.

Harb Gill, Windsor West

Conservative
“Government policies are making life too expensive for Canadians. Handing out temporary benefits will not fix high prices. We need a better plan to fix the economy.”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Relevance 8 of 100

    Only 8% of this question directly addressed the speech or the topic being debated.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, Canadians go to the grocery store and experience shock when they see the bill. If the government’s policies are making life more expensive, how does handing people another temporary benefit solve the problem? At some point, we have to put out the inflationary arson that is happening today in our economy. We cannot keep handing a homeowner a coupon for a fire extinguisher. I would ask my colleague this: Should we not come up with a better plan?

Michael Guglielmin, Vaughan—Woodbridge

Conservative
“The government measures success by how much money it spends instead of whether it helps create jobs and raise wages. We need to cut rules and lower taxes for people and businesses so companies want to invest here.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, one of the things I am noticing more is that the measure of success for the Liberal government far too often is how much money it spends. Really what we need to be measuring our success on is what conditions we create for new jobs to flourish, new companies to open and workers to make more money. How do we do that? It is by making the structural changes required in order to foster growth in this country, things like regulatory reform and tax reform, which are long overdue, both on the personal tax and the business tax side, so we can attract businesses and have them open here. Government cannot always pick winners and losers. What we need to do is create the conditions for businesses to want to invest, open, prosper and thrive. This could be the most competitive place to do business on planet earth. We have the resources we need. We really need to start putting our foot to the pedal here and making sure Canada can thrive.

Gérard Deltell, Louis-Saint-Laurent—Akiawenhrahk

Conservative
“The government gave Brazil $560 million to protect trees, but it is cutting budgets for local cadet programs. I want the member to explain this choice to the cadets.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my Liberal colleague for his speech. Now, here is another reality. This government is being heavily criticized for the choices it is making at the moment. It decided to give Brazil $560 million to protect trees. At the same time, we are learning that the cadets are facing severe budget restrictions that are preventing them from taking part in weekend activities. In my riding, this affects the optimist clubs, the optimist cadets of L’Ancienne‑Lorette, the Richelieu cadets of L’Ancienne‑Lorette, the Kondiaronk cadets of Loretteville and the cadets of Haute‑Saint‑Charles. What does the Liberal member have to say to the cadets?

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“I oppose this budget. The government plans to run nearly $300 billion in deficits over five years. Canadians are paying more in taxes but getting less in services. Debt is not free, and this budget spends $58 billion just on interest, which is more than ten percent of all government spending.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I wish you would be as generous with your time as the Liberal government is with taxpayer money in this budget. My goodness, this is a government that talks about being a new government, but it is amazing how much we see the old ways of spending. Actually, that is not fair. Justin Trudeau, believe it or not, looks like a fiscal conservative stacked up against the Liberal government’s budget now. This is a budget that could be termed “the young and the reckless”. It is forecasting deficits of nearly $300 billion over the next five years. This is not an abstract number when we realize what the real implications are of these deficits. Every dollar the government spends has to come from the taxpayer in some way. We know that. We all, as Canadians, accept that there is a balance. We pay a little in tax, and we get a little in services. Sometimes that balance is a lot more lopsided. Canadians now are paying more and more but getting less and less. When government chooses to spend outside of its means, as this government is, when governments choose to spend more than they are taxing Canadians, we end up with deficits that require the government to incur greater and greater levels of debt. That is what we are seeing here. Anyone who has ever taken out a mortgage or made a purchase on a credit card, things that ordinary Canadians are doing, knows debt is not free. Oftentimes, depending on a number of calculations, people end up spending more on interest than they did on the thing itself that required them to incur the debt. I would be remiss not to point out that the Liberal government’s reckless budget is resulting in more and more money being spent each year on nothing, on debt payments and interest. In this particular budget, the interest payments are $58 billion. That is more than one-tenth of the overall amount the government is spending, more than 10%. An hon. member: Billions, billions. Andrew Lawton: Mr. Speaker, it is interesting that I am being heckled by a former cabinet minister to Kathleen Wynne’s government in Ontario, who should really stay quiet right now when we are talking about debt and deficits and government spending. What could that $58 million— An hon. member: We were the only government to ever balance a budget. The former Conservatives never did that.

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“I oppose this budget. The government spends almost 59 billion dollars a year just paying interest on its debt, which enriches bankers instead of funding services or cutting taxes. It also plans to bring in a record number of new immigrants when we already face shortages in housing, health care, and jobs. The government must admit the harm its spending and debt will cause.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, that $58.7 billion could buy 50 new hospitals every single year. That money could double the entire federal health transfer, money the federal government gives to provinces to fund health care services. That amount could cut income taxes in this country by 25%. That money could eliminate the GST. These are all decisions a government could make if it had this money back in its coffers, or it could simply return the money to Canadians. This is why we have to talk about the recklessness of it. Every dollar spent in debt interest is a dollar spent enriching bankers and bondholders. It does not go to government services. It does not go to middle-class families. It does not go back into the pockets of Canadians who were taxed in the first place for the government to take that money. This is why when governments try to make big, flashy promises and pay for things they cannot afford, they end up loading more and more debt and more taxes onto future generations. The government claims this budget is called “Masters of our destiny”, but what it has mastered is indebtedness for future generations. It has mastered the illusion that governments can spend money recklessly, with abandon, and bear no consequences. It is not just the spending that is reckless. In this budget, the government has also put forward the most massive increase to immigration by way of increasing the number of permanent residents this country has ever seen. While housing is out of reach, health care resources are overstrained and unemployment is at record levels, the Liberals are planning to add 654,000 permanent residents in a single year, despite claiming that they are taking seriously the immigration crisis they have created. This number is 35% higher than the previous all-time record, which was set by Justin Trudeau. Yes, it is a new government, but new does not mean improved. There are new levels of debt, new levels of deficits, the same member for Winnipeg North and new levels of immigration, all of which continue to make life less affordable for Canadians, to make government less responsible and to aggravate and exacerbate the problems that Canadians have been grappling with and demanding that the government act on. This is a reckless budget that is putting reckless debt and deficits onto Canadians, which they cannot afford. The Liberal government would do well to acknowledge the harms this is going to cause for generations to come.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules