Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act

Bill C-41, Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act · Time allocation motion · now at committee in the House Where it stands

The debate was on a time allocation motion for Bill C-41, the Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act, which would allow people to make advance requests for medical assistance in dying before losing the capacity to consent, keep mental illness excluded as a sole basis for eligibility, and protect practitioners who follow provincial rules. The government said the issue has been studied for years, that safeguards let people withdraw consent at any time, and that some provinces are making rules that conflict with the Criminal Code, so the bill should pass quickly. Conservatives and Bloc Québécois members objected to cutting off debate after only one day, arguing a life-and-death matter needs fuller study; some asked whether a person would be told and asked again right before the procedure, and whether the government had provided its charter analysis. The Greens also opposed limiting debate, and one Conservative asked what the government would do about long waits for care. Some members said the House had not received the government’s analysis of the bill’s effects; others, including Conservatives and Bloc members, argued the timeline gave MPs too little time on a sensitive issue.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

37 statements

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“We should move forward with this bill now. We have studied and debated this issue for years, and we have heard from medical experts and people on all sides. We have all the information we need to make these changes to help people who are suffering.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I appreciate my Bloc Québécois colleague, but I disagree, given the circumstances surrounding this debate. Parliament has conducted a few studies on these issues, we have debated them in the House and the Senate, and the government has produced many reports. Now it is time to implement the changes, which are informed by the expertise of medical professionals and which reflect the need to address this disease for those who suffer from it. We have had many opportunities to debate this issue in public, in the chamber in this instance and in various parliamentary studies over the past number of years. In my view, we have the information we need to make decisions and have provided opportunity for various perspectives to be put forward on these important issues.

Michael Cooper, St. Albert—Sturgeon River

Conservative
“The government should not shut down debate on this bill. We have only debated it for one day. Letting people ask for medically assisted dying in advance has not been studied enough, and an expert panel warned against it. Without ongoing consent, a patient could receive it against their wishes. We need more time to debate this.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the time allocation motion is nothing short of outrageous. We have had one day of debate on a bill that significantly expands MAID with the introduction of advance requests. The last time advance requests were meaningfully studied was back in 2018, when the Council of Canadian Academies’ expert panel recommended against them. Since then, there has been no meaningful consultation and no meaningful study. The minister spoke of the special joint committee. I sat on that special joint committee. At best, the committee did a cursory review of advance requests. Advance requests raise profound legal, ethical and practical issues and present significant risks, including the very real risk that MAID could be administered against a patient’s wishes, absent contemporaneous consent. Given all of that, how can the minister possibly justify shutting down debate?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“I want this bill to pass now. It respects patients by letting them ask for medically assisted dying in advance, before their health gets worse. It also protects them from unbearable suffering. Parliament and health officials have already studied this enough, and it is time to act.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, one element of the question was directed at a central issue. It is about respecting a patient’s wishes. We clearly hold a different view. We wish to move forward with a regime that provides for advance requests. In fact, the legislation would not create the regime in provincial health systems but would simply decriminalize the practice where there is a provincial regime in place. The reason we want to move forward is about giving agency and respecting the patient’s request. To do otherwise would be to condemn them to experience a death that is intolerable, in the level of suffering they would experience, with a known result and a continued deterioration. We want to do what we can to give agency to those individuals. We have, at a government level, with the Department of Health, and as a Parliament, been able to study these and related issues. The time to move forward is now.

Doly Begum, Scarborough Southwest

Liberal
“People in my riding have shared deep personal stories about this bill. I want the minister to explain what he has heard and why we must pass it quickly.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, in my time here, just over the last month, I have heard from my constituents on this very important bill. We have heard many personal and deeply emotional stories throughout this debate. I would like to give the minister an opportunity to share some of his experiences. What has he heard, and why is it so important to move forward efficiently and effectively with this legislation?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“I want this bill to pass. People in my community want to make advance requests for medically assisted dying so their families do not have to watch them suffer from memory loss and serious illness.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 24 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the stories capture the human element behind these very difficult debates, and I appreciate the member giving me this opportunity. Perhaps one that stands out for me more than others was from a member of my community. He is a stand-up citizen whose partner is a wonderful and beloved artist in our community. He shared with me the experience of living through a terrible set of circumstances when his mother was diagnosed with a condition that caused her to forget her family, that caused her to become unknown and a very different version of herself, which was hard not only on her as a patient but of course on the family as well. Upon being diagnosed with the same condition, he expressed to me a strong desire to ensure that he had the ability to not make his family go through what he went through. These human experiences have become all too common in my conversations with people who now treat this legislation as an opportunity to minimize the suffering they experience as well as the suffering their families are required to live through.

Alex Ruff, Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound

Conservative
“I want a yes or no answer from the Minister of Justice. Is there a legal deadline to pass the rules for advance requests?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my question to the Minister of Justice is very simple. We understand there is a legal timeline or deadline with respect to the part of the bill that deals with the exclusion of MAID for mental illness alone. Is there a legal requirement or deadline tied to advance requests, yes or no?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“We want to allow advance requests to prevent terrible suffering. People with illnesses that cannot be cured should be able to end their lives in a way that minimizes pain for them and their families.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 46 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the motivation we have to deal with the advance request issue is to prevent the extraordinary human suffering that exists every day. I wish to extend protections to people who are living with a diagnosis today where there is intolerable suffering of an irremediable nature so that they know what is coming, which would give them an opportunity to transition from this life in a way that minimizes the pain and suffering they and their families live through.

Martin Champoux, Drummond

Bloc Québécois
“We need more time to debate this bill about medically assisted dying. These issues are very sensitive and will change our society. We have not finished talking about mental illness and other key points. The minister should not cut off debate.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I agree with what my colleague from Rivière-du-Nord said earlier. These are such important issues, because they affect our society so profoundly and will change it drastically, change our approach to dealing with illness at the end of life. These are extremely sensitive and extremely important issues, and we need to take our time and debate them thoroughly. The government cannot simply say that it is the government and that it has enough information to make a decision, so it does not need Parliament anymore because it is going to move forward and do whatever it wants. Other aspects of this bill are very important. There is the issue of mental illness, which we have not finished debating. Yes, Quebec has already taken the lead on advance requests since 2023, but there are still other matters we should debate and discuss. It is truly troubling to see this minister, who is generally known for working collaboratively with others, show up today with a time allocation motion on such a delicate and sensitive issue, when our constituents are asking us to explore it and debate it further to clarify these points, which, I repeat, are extremely sensitive.

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“We have debated this bill enough to move it forward. We have spent eight hours debating it here, past studies have looked at it, and a committee will study it next. We listened to different parties and experts to write it. We should keep moving it through Parliament.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I agree with my colleague that these issues are important. I take a different point of view as to the opportunity that parliamentarians have had or will have to put their perspectives on the record, to vote with their conscience and to represent the folks who have elected them to serve in this particular chamber. We are not dismissing different points of view. In fact, taking together considerations from different parties, different perspectives and different communities of expertise and advocacy is how we arrived at the conclusion we did. We have had eight hours of debate in this chamber. We will have an opportunity at committee to hear more. We are standing on the shoulders of studies, both joint studies between the Senate and Parliament, as well as previous debates that included proposed amendments on these issues. We believe we have identified the path forward. I welcome continued consideration of this through the parliamentary process that remains.

Costas Menegakis, Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill

Conservative
“The government is rushing this bill about life and death. It was introduced only 20 days ago, and now the minister wants to shut down debate. We should not rush this. We need to split the bill, debate it more, and listen to Canadians.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it took the government two years to discuss and debate changing two words in Canada’s national anthem. The bill before us, which deals with life or death, was introduced by the minister on October 27, just 20 days ago. In the past 20 days, for one full week Parliament was not sitting. Today the minister is asking us to shut down debate and shut down any further discussion. He is refusing to split the bill, with no discussion whatsoever on a matter as important as life or death. Why the urgency? Why not split the bill? Why not discuss it further? Why not debate it further? Why not hear from stakeholders across the country? Why not hear from Canadians? Why rush it through the House at warp speed?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“We should keep this bill together and pass it. It will stop real suffering for people who are dying and losing the ability to make their own choices. The same experts can help us study both parts of the bill at the same time.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, a repeated theme from members of the Conservative Party has been to split the bill. Although unanimity would be preferred, it is not the goal. Preventing the real suffering people are living through is the goal. As we have this debate in Parliament, there are people living with deadly diagnoses that have or will steal their capacity to make decisions for themselves and result in a certain and painful death characterized by intolerable suffering. We have an opportunity to prevent the suffering that many vulnerable Canadians and their families will live through. In addition, it makes sense to study multiple issues together when dealing with the same community of advocates and experts who will have perspectives on the two issues that are the central themes of this bill.

Ellis Ross, Skeena—Bulkley Valley

Conservative
“This bill combines two different issues. We already agree on stopping medically assisted dying for mental illness. The part about advance consent needs much more study. Eight hours of debate is not enough time for a life-and-death issue. Does the minister agree that we need more time to properly debate this bill?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, we are talking about two issues here. One is about accessing MAID for mental health, which everybody agrees with. That could have been approved through Bill C-218. The minister talks about there being an issue with it. It could have been amended and would be a done deal. We are talking about advance consent. Parliamentarians are expected to debate this within eight hours, but the minister keeps going back to studies that were done 10 years ago. Our job as MPs is to represent the people’s wishes and feelings. Eight hours is not enough time. Does the minister agree that Parliament’s job is to assess and debate important bills like this one, which deal with life and death?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“The Conservatives say they need more time to study this issue, but they also wanted to rush it through with their own bill. We had real problems with their bill. Our bill is based on deep work by government experts. I want this bill sent to committee now so it can get the deep study they are asking for.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the Conservatives are making two arguments that are mutually exclusive. On the one hand, they say they need more time to study it. On the other hand, they say it could have been done through a Conservative private member’s bill. They take the abbreviated process with less debate than has been taking place already. We have had substantive issues with the proposed private member’s bill. We thought it was best to benefit from the deep policy work that went on at the Department of Justice and the Department of Health to move forward with multiple issues that are a very serious concern. If the member is concerned that there has not been enough debate so far, we are moving that this bill go to the next stage of proceedings, which involves an in-depth study before the parliamentary committee, to be returned to this House for debate.

Andrew Lawton, Elgin—St. Thomas—London South

Conservative
“A parliamentary committee heard about people getting medically assisted dying despite mental illness, unclear consent, or rushed assessments. I want the minister to answer yes or no: are the current safeguards working?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying heard of the case of Kiano Vafaeian, a 26-year-old denied MAID in Ontario but given it in British Columbia when he was struggling with mental illness even before that was allowed as a primary request. It heard of the case of Donna Duncan, where there was ambiguity about whether she actually wanted it. Then, in St. Thomas, a man was assessed for MAID in the parking lot of a Tim Hortons and driven by his doctor to a funeral home, where he received MAID the same day. I would like a yes or no. Does the minister believe existing MAID safeguards are working?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal
“I want the House to pass this bill. It permanently bans medically assisted dying for people whose only illness is mental illness. It also protects people who face terrible suffering and will lose the ability to make their own choices, and it makes sure doctors and nurses who help them are not treated like criminals.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, through this legislation, the safeguards would be strengthened, specifically including the indeterminate exclusion of medical assistance in dying under the Criminal Code where mental illness is the sole underlying medical condition. I know the member cares deeply about this issue. I respect his position. It helped inform the government’s decision when we landed on our conclusion on the issue solely dealing with mental illness. For each of the people that he has mentioned, I can tell him that there are real people living in real communities who are diagnosed with illnesses that are going to take their capacity and agency and condemn them to a death that is characterized by intolerable suffering. I do not think that is an outcome I am comfortable with. We should change Canada’s Criminal Code to ensure that the medical practitioners who minimize suffering are not treated as criminals.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“I want the minister to answer my question with a yes or no. If a patient's life is ended because of an advance request, will someone tell them what is about to happen and ask for their consent right before it happens?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, what is considered intolerable suffering is supposed to be relative to the subjective assessment of the patients themselves, yet the minister did not answer my question. Will the patient be told what is about to happen to them when it is about to happen to them? I will ask it again. If a patient’s life is being ended based on an advance request, will they be told what is about to happen to them and asked for their contemporaneous consent before it happens, regardless of capacity? Will they be told, yes or no?

Sean Fraser, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and Minister responsible for the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency

Liberal

Linked statement

“This bill lets patients set conditions to receive medical assistance in dying before they lose the ability to consent. They can change their mind at any time before that. It will only happen if their own conditions are met and multiple doctors agree their suffering is intolerable. The provinces will add more specific rules later.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 24 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, there are clearly going to be some specific details on provincial safeguards that will be legislated subsequent to the adoption of this legislation. This legislation would create an opportunity for that patient to determine the conditions under which they would access medical assistance in dying before they lose their capacity, with an opportunity to withdraw or revoke that consent at any time. It will be administered only when multiple medical professionals agree that the level of suffering the patient is living through is intolerable. The conditions they decide for themselves must be met.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements