Government Orders

Bill C-41, Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act · Second reading · now at committee in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-41 would do

The bill would allow doctors and nurse practitioners to provide medical assistance in dying to a person who has lost the capacity to consent, if the person made an advance request while they still had capacity. To qualify, the person must have been diagnosed beforehand with a serious and incurable condition expected to cause an irreversible loss of capacity, and their province must have a legislative system to store and manage those requests. The bill would also keep the exclusion in place that prevents a person from receiving assisted dying solely for a mental illness.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

23 statements

Ned Kuruc, Hamilton East—Stoney Creek

Conservative

Linked statement

“I want the government to split this bill into two. I support the part that permanently stops assisted dying for people whose only issue is mental illness. They need treatment and hope, not death. But I oppose the part that lets people ask in advance for assisted dying before they lose their mental capacity. Their wishes could change years later, and doctors should not have to guess what a patient wants. We need to pass the mental illness ban now, and take more time to study advance requests separately.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I rise today to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. This is not an easy subject to discuss. We are talking about some of the most vulnerable Canadians in our country: people living with mental illness, people suffering from serious medical conditions and families facing some of the most difficult decisions imaginable. The decisions we make in the House will have real, irreversible consequences for these Canadians. That is why we have a responsibility to get it right and to treat the bill with care. Bill C-41 proposes two very different changes to Canada’s laws on medical assistance in dying. The first would permanently exclude mental illness as the sole underlying medical condition for MAID. The second would allow certain Canadians to make advance requests for MAID, which could be carried out after they have lost the ability to provide informed consent. I strongly support the first part of the legislation. However, the second part raises very serious concerns about consent, patient autonomy and the protection of vulnerable Canadians. I believe that these two issues deserve to be considered separately. Mental illness affects families in every community across this country, including right at home in Hamilton East—Stoney Creek. Whether someone is struggling with depression, post-traumatic stress disorder or other serious mental health conditions, their suffering is very real. However, what troubles me deeply is the idea that someone struggling with their mental health could see medically assisted death presented as an alternative to getting the treatment and support they desperately need. Canadians struggling with mental illness need treatment, resources, support and, above all, hope. Unfortunately, we have already seen deeply troubling examples of MAID’s being proposed to Canadians who are simply trying to get help. In 2022, Canadians learned that a Veterans Affairs employee had inappropriately discussed medical assistance in dying with veterans. One veteran seeking treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury reported that MAID was brought up during his dealings with Veterans Affairs. He was not asking for assistance in dying; he was asking for help. A subsequent Veterans Affairs investigation confirmed four inappropriate MAID discussions. I find it absolutely heartbreaking that even one veteran had to experience something like this. When a veteran reaches out for help, our response should be to provide that help, not to suggest ending their life. This issue also extends beyond our veterans. In 2023, a woman named Kathrin Mentler went to the Vancouver General Hospital while experiencing a serious mental health crisis. She was struggling with depression and suicidal thoughts. According to her account, during her assessment, a physician asked her whether she had considered medical assistance in dying. The health authority later characterized the discussion is part of a clinical risk assessment rather than an offer of MAID. Regardless of how that conversation was intended, we must recognize the distress it caused someone who had come looking for help. Imagine the courage it takes for someone struggling with suicidal thoughts to reach out and ask for help. Now imagine how devastating it would be to hear MAID raised during that conversation. When someone is struggling, our job is not to give up on them. Our job is to help them get better. That means improving access to psychiatrists, psychologists, counselling, crisis intervention and long-term mental health support. It means making sure Canadians are not left waiting months to receive treatment when they need help today. That is why I support permanently excluding mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID. That brings me to the second part of the bill, and this is where I have very serious concerns. Bill C-41 would allow someone diagnosed with a qualifying serious and incurable illness such as Alzheimer’s disease to make an advance request for MAID. That request could potentially be carried out after the person has lost the mental capacity to consent. I understand why this is being proposed. I understand that there are Canadians who fear losing their independence, their memories and eventually the ability to make decisions themselves. I recognize that this bill includes eligibility requirements, medical assessments and safeguards, as well as requirements for provincial or territorial legislation, but the existence of safeguards would not mean every ethical question has been answered. Should consent that was given months or years in advance remain valid when the individual is no longer mentally capable of consenting? There is something particularly concerning about this legislation. Bill C-41 establishes no federal maximum time limit between the signing of the advance request and when it could eventually be carried out. That means a request signed 10, 15 or even 20 years earlier could potentially still be considered, provided the patient meets the eligibility criteria and applicable provincial requirements. Members can think about what that means. Imagine someone diagnosed with early onset Alzheimer’s disease at the age of 50. They make an advance request fearing what their future might look like, but 15 years later, their condition has progressed and they can no longer provide informed consent. Should a decision made 15 years earlier be enough to authorize ending that person’s life today? How can we know their wishes have not changed? How can we know the life they are living today is the life they imagined when they signed that request? People change. Their circumstances change. Their perspectives change. Someone diagnosed with dementia may initially fear that their life will no longer be worth living once their condition progresses, but years later, despite their cognitive decline, they may still experience happiness, comfort, connection and, most importantly, love. How can we be certain that the decision they made years earlier is still the decision they would make today? We are talking about an irreversible decision, and it deserves extreme caution. Another major concern is the responsibility this legislation would place on medical professionals. Ultimately, it would not be members of Parliament administering these advance requests. It would be doctors and nurse practitioners. I recognize that the bill would protect medical professionals from being compelled to participate, but for those who do, the responsibility is enormous. How does a medical professional determine whether someone who can no longer communicate clearly is experiencing intolerable suffering? How do they distinguish between an involuntary reaction and an attempt to resist? The bill says that, if a patient clearly demonstrates refusal or resistance, the doctor cannot proceed with MAID, but what happens when their behaviour is unclear? The legislation requires a delay of at least 30 days when the medical professional is uncertain whether the patient is refusing or resisting, but what would waiting 30 days necessarily resolve? Will that resolve that uncertainty? How can we expect doctors and nurse practitioners to interpret someone’s final wishes when that individual can no longer provide informed consent? These are enormous ethical and professional responsibilities. Before Parliament moves forward, we must hear directly from those who would be responsible for administering the legislation. We need to consult doctors, nurses, psychiatrists, palliative care specialists and those who work directly with patients experiencing cognitive decline. We need to understand whether they believe these safeguards are sufficient. We need to understand the consequences if an irreversible mistake were to be made. We cannot simply pass legislation in Ottawa and leave medical professionals to wrestle with these questions on their own. That is why I believe these two parts of Bill C-41 must be separated. We should move forward with permanently excluding mental illness as the sole underlying condition for MAID, but advance requests deserve their own legislation, their own debate and a thorough examination. There should be no rush when the consequences are irreversible. I want to finish with this: Behind every discussion about medical assistance in dying is a real person, a father, a mother, a son, a daughter, a grandparent, someone who is loved, someone whose life matters, someone who may be facing the darkest and most frightening chapter of their life. I think about the veteran struggling with PTSD who simply wants treatment. We must never allow the lack of resources, the lack of treatment or the lack of support to leave vulnerable Canadians feeling that death is their only option. We must be a country that offers hope to those who are struggling, care to those who are suffering and protection to those who are vulnerable. That is the responsibility we have been entrusted with, and that is the responsibility we must uphold. I urge the Liberals to consider making these two issues their own separate bills, so we can give both the attention they deserve.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“We have debated medically assisted dying for a long time. The federal government sets the rules and safeguards in criminal law, but the provinces have to run the system. I want to know what the member thinks about the role the provinces play.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, first, I appreciate the comments the member made. I want to amplify the fact that, virtually since 2015, there has been a tremendous amount of debate and discussion on a wide spectrum of issues with respect to MAID. When we get down to what the federal government is doing through the passage of this legislation, which was ultimately dictated because of a superior court decision back in 2014, we would be establishing through criminal law who qualifies for MAID. We also then put in guardrails, and that is something this legislation continues to do. The provinces, on the other hand, have a responsibility in how it would be administered. I wonder if the member can provide his thoughts on the role provinces have to play.

Ned Kuruc, Hamilton East—Stoney Creek

Conservative
“A close friend of mine wanted to die after a terrible surgery, but he recovered and now has a family and business. I worry people might choose to end their lives at their lowest point and miss the chance to get better.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 0 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Signal 0 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, for me it is a very difficult topic to talk about because I have a very good friend who at one point had a very terrible surgery and lost his life on the table. He subsequently had massive heart attacks and was left in a coma for months and months. When he came to, he came out of the coma and was on every single piece of life support that was possible. He tried to commit suicide once he could get the use of his right hand, and then after that, he tried to commit suicide again. If he had been able, at that point, to sign a piece of paper or talk about what would happen if he took a turn for the worse, his life surely would have ended, but today he has made a full recovery. He has a beautiful four-year-old daughter Irina, a successful business and a wonderful family, so this is a little difficult for me to answer.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“I oppose this bill. It lets someone else decide if a person is suffering too much based on a paper signed years ago, without asking that person how they feel right now. It would allow someone to be killed without even telling them what is about to happen.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, earlier today the justice minister was talking about people facing intolerable suffering. The problem with this advance request structure is that it would involve somebody else, a third party, determining what is intolerable to them without even a requirement that the person be asked or consulted in the moment about the state of their suffering. It would involve an external third party assessment, according to a document that was signed potentially years or decades before, about what is intolerable to an individual who is not being consulted. That is obviously absurd. We cannot assess what is intolerable to a person without at least asking them about their own present subjective experience, yet Bill C-41 would allow someone to be killed without them even being told what is about to happen to them. I want to thank the member for highlighting the concerns he has about this framework and just ask if he has anything else he wants to add.

Ned Kuruc, Hamilton East—Stoney Creek

Conservative
“I want us to separate the parts of this bill. A voter with schizophrenia told me she is terrified. She worries that if she is off her medication, she or someone else could sign a request for assisted death without her knowing, and she could be killed instead of helped.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, there is. I had a very difficult conversation with a member of my community who suffers from schizophrenia. She called me, and an announcement that she had seen on what we are doing up here in Parliament was a very traumatic experience for her, because she admitted that, when she is off her meds, she does not know what is going to happen to her. She said her fear is that, when she goes off of her meds, somebody, whether that is a third party, a family member or even she herself, could sign something without her knowing. She could then not get help and possibly be killed. She was just hysterical on the phone with me, sobbing and crying. She just wants to be in control of her own decisions, and her fear is that, if we do not separate these bills, that could be lost.

Elizabeth May, Saanich—Gulf Islands

Green
“Most people in my riding want the right to choose medically assisted dying in advance if they get dementia or ALS. I want to know what we should tell them.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, these are clearly difficult issues. I have always been very honoured to debate issues of medical assistance in dying in this place. Despite differences across the aisles, this is one of those discussions we have that is almost devoid of cheap shots and snide partisanship because these are life-and-death questions. To my hon. colleague, I ask what we would say. Within my community, I can say for sure that the majority of my constituents are begging for advance directives to be able to say that, if they are diagnosed with ALS, or if they are diagnosed with dementia, they want the ability to choose death with dignity while they are in their right mind. What would we say to those people?

Ned Kuruc, Hamilton East—Stoney Creek

Conservative
“We should split this bill into two parts. We should pass the part we all agree on right away. We need to debate and study the other part much more carefully.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 48 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the logical solution is to separate these bills. Let us move forward on the bill that we all agree on, but let us really debate, scrutinize and hear from everybody, possibly that colleague or any colleague in the House, to debate that second part. It needs more thorough investigation.

Roman Baber, North York

Conservative
“Medically assisted dying in Canada has gone too far. One in 20 Canadians who died in 2024 died this way. I support the part of this bill that bans assisted dying for people whose only issue is mental illness, because they cannot give proper consent. But I have serious concerns about letting people ask for it in advance. We should help people with mental health care instead of offering them death.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, medical assistance in dying in Canada is now a disaster. In 2024, 16,499 Canadians died by MAID, which was 5.1% of all deaths in Canada in 2024. That is one in 20 Canadians dying by medical assistance in dying. It is an unthinkable number. Compared to other countries, Canada has the highest mortality rate by MAID, followed by the Netherlands and Belgium. How did we get here? We were not supposed to. In the 2015 Carter versus Attorney General decision, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that Canada’s prohibition on physician-assisted suicide violated section 7 of the charter. Attempting suicide has not been a crime in Canada since 1972, but counselling or aiding suicide is still an offence under section 241 of the Criminal Code and carries a maximum penalty of 14 years. In the Carter decision, the Supreme Court held that a blanket prohibition on physician-assisted suicide is contrary to the charter’s right to life, liberty and security of a person. The court ruled that medical assistance in dying is permitted for competent adults, and I stress “competent”, who are experiencing enduring and intolerable suffering from a grievous incurable condition, which was the second stipulation. Again, the key phrase was “competent adults”. Competence requires consent. There are two basic elements to competence. A person must be the age of majority, otherwise they cannot consent, and they must be of sound mind. That is the key. That is why it was so outrageous that the Liberals sought to expand, at some point, MAID to teenagers, and equally repugnant was their attempt to expand MAID to those whose sole underlying condition was mental illness. How can someone who is not of sound mind consent to die? How could we entertain such cruelty that we would administer a lethal injection to someone who may not be able to consent to a lethal injection? I am blessed in my role as shadow minister for civil liberties. I have a unique perspective on civil liberties, having been born and lived the first eight years of my life in the communist Soviet Union. Section 7, the right to life, liberty and security, is perhaps the most precious right in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. What else could be more important than life, liberty and security of a person? These are the most primal instincts we have as human beings, and I will not second-guess the Supreme Court in Carter. I agree that a consenting individual of sound mind should be able to say, under the right circumstances, “I don’t want to suffer anymore. I don’t want to lose my dignity. I don’t want to subject my loved ones to pain.” It is their life, their liberty and their security, which is often interpreted as a right to their own body, but that is because it is their decision. It is their decision because they are competent to make such a decision and they can grant consent, but if a person is not an adult, or is suffering from mental illness, then how can they grant consent? If there is no consent, then it is no longer medical assistance in dying. What MAID turned into in Canada is not what it was meant to be. In response to the Carter decision, Canada legalized MAID in 2016, which is for adults who are able to consent and who are experiencing intolerable suffering from a terminal condition that is irreversible. At the time, the law required that death was reasonably foreseeable. That requirement of death being reasonably foreseeable was struck down by the courts, forcing Parliament to expand eligibility further, except the Liberals were liberal, and eligibility was considered for people whose sole underlying condition was mental illness. Thankfully, through Bill C-7, the Criminal Code was amended to include a two-year prohibition on availability of MAID for individuals whose sole underlying condition was mental illness. Then, twice more, in 2023 and 2024, the mental illness exclusion was extended again, moving the deadline to March 2027. Conservatives have always been on the right side of this question. We fought tooth and nail against the expansion of MAID to teenagers. We fought tooth and nail against MAID for those whose sole medical condition was mental illness, and now we have finally won. We can think about how much worry the emotional roller coaster of the Liberals has put so many families through, worrying that a loved one may not be able to hold on and, god forbid, take their own life. We have a mental health epidemic in our country. CAMH estimates that 20% of Canadians are suffering from mental illness. That is significantly higher than the global average and puts us in the top tier of countries experiencing mental illness. Twenty-six per cent of Canadians aged 16 to 21 report suffering from poor mental health. That is a catastrophe. I still maintain that it was our pandemic response, the fact that Canada, and my province of Ontario, had the longest lockdown in the world, that sparked this mental health epidemic that we cannot seem to get out of. I was the only one in this building to publicly oppose the lockdown of 2020-21, albeit that I was in the provincial legislature at the time. The Liberals wanted to expand MAID to people suffering from mental illness. Thankfully, with this legislation, Bill C-41, they are rolling it back. There are material concerns with respect to the second portion of the bill, which is advance requests, but on mental illness, the Liberals could have just voted for Conservative bills. They could have voted for Bill C-218, brought by the Conservative member for Cloverdale—Langley City. Her bill would have permanently blocked the expansion of MAID to individuals whose sole medical condition is mental illness, but they voted against it. What happened to MAID in Canada? In my province, Ontario, patients can wait for more than two years to get an appointment with a psychiatrist. There are cities such as Kingston, where at some point it was three years to get an appointment with a psychiatrist, but they could get track 2 MAID in as little as 90 days. In some cases, for track 1 MAID, there was no wait time at all. This is not what the Supreme Court had in mind in Carter. We hear horror stories of veterans being told that they are eligible for MAID when all they asked for was basic disability benefits and mental health supports. People are known to be considering MAID in food banks. That is the Prime Minister’s economy. This is why I support my friend’s bill, Bill C-260, by the Conservative member for Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan. Bill C-260 would preclude anyone who is not a health care practitioner from offering MAID. We have a MAID factory in this country, not as an act of compassion, as it was meant to be, but as a standard operating procedure that is not health care or compassion. We have a crisis in mental health and addictions. Imagine the result of this crisis perpetuating itself and extending onto MAID. We need to rethink the entire MAID regime. I pray for the lives that will be saved because MAID will not be available to individuals whose sole condition is mental illness. Let us invest in mental health treatment and supports. Let us invest in more doctors, nurses and hospital beds. Let us not allow people who cannot consent to MAID to consent to MAID.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“Canada's laws on medical assistance in dying have grown over time, and other countries are now copying what we did. I think this was the right path. I want to know what the member thinks about how this issue has changed.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I think it is important to recognize the whole issue and debate. I could go back to the early 1990s, with Sue Rodriguez and the impact of that Supreme Court decision back then. It evolved in 2015, when the then Harper government refused to deal with the issue. We brought forward legislation that set the framework in terms of changing the Criminal Code. What we have seen is that it has evolved to where it is today. In fact, if we go back to 2015, there might have been a half dozen other countries. Since we passed MAID, I can tell that other countries have been watching what Canada has been doing on this very sensitive issue. Now there are a number of countries that are following suit, because it is the right way to go. I am wondering if the member could provide his thoughts on what seems to be an evolving issue.

Roman Baber, North York

Conservative
“The Liberals should stop blaming the Harper government, which has not been in power for 11 years. In 2024, one in 20 deaths in Canada was through medically assisted dying. That is 5% of all deaths. The system was never supposed to expand this much, and I blame the Liberal government for it.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I think it is shameful that the member, and in fact, the government, continually refer to the Harper government, which has not sat in this building for 11 years. The Carter decision came down in 2015, which is the same year that the member’s government was elected, and it is the same old Liberal government. On the issue, yes, it has evolved. It has evolved such that in 2024, 5% of total deaths in Canada were by virtue of medical assistance in dying. One in 20 Canadians who die are choosing MAID. It was never supposed to evolve to this, and that is thanks to the member and the Liberal government.

Costas Menegakis, Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill

Conservative
“This bill is about life and death. Parliament spent months debating our flag and years debating our anthem. I want to know why the government is rushing this bill through without enough debate.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, we are talking about a bill that deals with life and death in this country. It took six months for Parliament to debate and discuss the Canadian flag. It took almost two years for the House to discuss changing just two words in the national anthem. Can the member share with us why he thinks the Liberal government is so hell-bent on passing this bill, which deals with life and death, so quickly, without proper debate in this place?

Roman Baber, North York

Conservative
“The Liberals just cut off debate on this bill after only one day. This bill deals with serious issues, like letting people ask for medically assisted dying in advance and letting people with mental illness get it. It is shameful to stop debate on a bill this important.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is worth pointing out that I rose not during ordinary debate at second reading, but during time allocation of this bill. The Liberals just passed a motion cutting off debate on this key piece of legislation, which would not only cease to limit MAID to people whose sole underlying condition is mental illness but also deal with advance requests, where one could ask for MAID in advance. It is on this piece of legislation that the Liberals will allow only one House sitting day of debate, and that is shameful.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“I worry this bill lets people sign up for assisted dying in advance when they are scared and being pressured by officials. Later on, they could be killed based on that paper without anyone asking them again. I want the member to share his thoughts on this danger.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague both for an excellent speech and for his kind words about my bill, Bill C-260. The bill is aimed at addressing the issue of MAID coercion, when people are trying to access support from authority figures and are pressured or pushed to consider MAID, oftentimes by professionals who are not even supposed to be involved in MAID, like bureaucrats at Veterans Affairs, social workers and other such people, even outside of the medical system. With Bill C-41, I see a potential toxic combination of advance requests with coercion, where a person gets a diagnosis and is not very familiar with what the implications are. They feel a lot of pressure and fear, because they do not have any lived experience with what that is actually going to be like. They then sign a piece of paper and effectively sign away their future autonomy. Bill C-41 would allow someone to be killed at a future point without even being asked, based on a piece of paper they signed in the past. Can the member comment on how this combination of factors could impact people?

Roman Baber, North York

Conservative
“I support my colleague's bill. Only doctors and health professionals should be allowed to suggest medically assisted dying. Government workers and social workers should not be offering it to vulnerable people, including people who use food banks.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 46 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I commend my friend’s bill, Bill C-260. It is unconscionable and unthinkable that anyone other than a regulated health professional would offer MAID or explain to someone that there is an option for MAID. Most often, these are people who are seeking help from a government bureaucrat or potentially seeking help from a social worker. They are often people who attend food banks. We have a crisis vis-à-vis MAID in country, and I appreciate my friend’s attempt to narrow the scope of those who are able to offer MAID to health practitioners only.

Kent MacDonald, Cardigan

Liberal
“I want the House to pass this bill. It lets people with illnesses like dementia make advance requests for medically assisted dying. It also stops medically assisted dying from being expanded to people whose only condition is a mental illness. Experts still cannot agree on how to safely assess those cases. Instead, the government is sending billions of dollars to the provinces to improve mental health care. The bill also cuts down on paperwork for doctors and tracks better data.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I welcome the opportunity to speak to Bill C-41, the medical assistance in dying safeguards act. This is a deeply sensitive and personal topic for many Canadians, including myself. It involves complex medical, legal and ethical considerations. I have heard from many of my constituents and taken their viewpoints under consideration in forming my own position. To address these considerations, this legislation would make two critical changes. It would, first of all, permit individuals diagnosed with degenerative illnesses such as Alzheimer’s and dementia to make an advance MAID request following provincial and territorial health protocols. It would also end the expansion of MAID where mental illness is the sole underlying condition. We recognize that mental illness can cause suffering just as profound as physical illness. At the same time, there are differing views on whether eligibility for MAID can be reliably assessed and provided safely. Our decision-making has been guided by the need to carefully balance respect for personal autonomy with the need to protect those who may be vulnerable. It carefully responds to public concern, parliamentary study and expert testimony, holistically reflecting Canada’s readiness for MAID expansion. Bill C-41 also aims to improve data collection and reporting practices for MAID, allowing Canadians to better understand how MAID is provided throughout the country. This legislation focuses its approach on compassion, caution and respect, taking the time to scrutinize MAID readiness for mental illness eligibility. Bill C-41 would maintain the exclusion for people whose sole underlying mental condition is a mental illness. This issue has been the subject of substantial study and debate for the past decade, yet no real consensus has emerged. We know that mental illness can cause profound and intolerable suffering, equal to the suffering that a physical illness can cause. At the same time, experts continue to raise serious questions about whether requests for MAID based solely on mental illness can be assessed safely and consistently. They have identified challenges in determining whether a mental illness can be treated. They have also questioned whether practitioners can reliably assess a request for MAID that is based on recent decision-making rather than suicidal intention. Parliament’s very own Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying has studied the issue multiple times, issuing reports in 2023, 2024 and, most recently, 2026. It concluded that the scheduled expansion should not proceed. Canadians expect us to carefully consider and weigh the right approach, including balancing competing rights around personal autonomy with the need to protect those who may be vulnerable. I recognize that this decision will be difficult for some people. It also underscores the importance of ensuring that people living with mental illness have access to the care and support they need. There are people across our country who have suffered from mental illness for many years without finding relief. Some have considered MAID seriously. After deep reflection, I recognize that this decision may be very distressing for them. The suffering caused by a mental illness is just as real and serious as the suffering caused by a physical illness. Severe mental illness can have a devastating impact on one’s quality of life. People living with mental illness need timely, appropriate support, no matter where they live. This is especially important in rural and remote areas like the one I represent, where it can be difficult to access quality care. Since 2017, the Government of Canada has been working with provinces and territories to improve access to quality mental health services. In 2023, the government announced the working together to improve health care for Canadians plan, providing $200 billion over 10 years to provinces and territories, including $25 billion for shared priorities, such as mental health. We are also working with provinces and territories to renew these agreements, providing more stable, longer-term funding while allowing them to respond to the needs of their communities. Building on this work, earlier this month, the health minister met with provincial and territorial health ministers in Winnipeg. They reaffirmed a shared commitment to improve access to mental health services. At that meeting, the Government of Canada announced an additional $1.2-billion extension for 2027-28. The investment includes federal support to provinces and territories for mental health services, while federal, provincial and territorial governments continue discussions on long-term health funding, sustainability and finding better ways to deliver high-quality care for Canadians. Before I conclude, I want to touch on how Bill C-41 would improve MAID data collection and reporting. Accurate data collection and public reporting are essential to transparency and accountability. Reliable information helps us understand who is requesting MAID, under what circumstances and why. Bill C-41 would seek to strengthen data collection and reporting by collecting new information related to advance requests. It would seek to improve administrative efficiency by streamlining some reporting requirements. The proposed legislative changes would expand the collection of data on advance requests in order to inform the public on the provision of MAID in Canada, take out requirements for preliminary assessors to provide reports, and permit others to help physicians and nurse practitioners with reporting. These measures, combined with maintaining accountability, would lower the burden of unnecessary paperwork for our health care practitioners. Lived experiences and expert testimonies have guided these vulnerable conversations. Having listened to a broad array of testimonies from Canadians coast to coast, we extend these changes with prudence and dignity. We have engaged partners who have shared their perspectives and made two critical decisions around MAID for advance requests and mental illness as the sole underlying condition. As discussed, the legislation would put firm guardrails around advance requests. Crucially, it would end the extension of MAID where the sole underlying condition is mental illness. Bill C-41 maintains respect for autonomy while confronting the honest reality around Canada’s readiness for MAID expansion. While difficult, the government prioritizes transparency and accountability regarding MAID expansion, which is why it continues to build its efforts to improve MAID data collection and reporting. On a more personal note, I think many members of the House have probably sat with a dying relative. This type of lived experience definitely influences the way one looks at MAID as a personal choice for Canadians. The legislation would prioritize the individual while following the need for a compassionate, respectful and prudent response. I ask that all members of the House support the bill.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“Will Liberal members get a free vote on this bill?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have a simple question for my colleague. I wonder if he could share with the House whether Liberal members will be given a free vote on this issue of conscience.

Kent MacDonald, Cardigan

Liberal
“I have not consulted on this. Members usually vote with their conscience on private members' bills, and I expect them to do the same for this one.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I have not had any consultations. On most private members’ bills or legislation, members vote their conscience, and I know it is no different for this bill.

Doug Eyolfson, Winnipeg West

Liberal
“I agree that people should not get medically assisted dying only because of mental illness. But people should be allowed to ask for it in advance, before dementia takes away their ability to choose.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I agree wholeheartedly with the government’s plan to prohibit MAID where the sole reason is mental illness. The thought of doing that made me, as a physician, nervous. However, as someone who has watched people suffer from dementia, as someone who has watched members of my own family suffer from dementia and does not wish to undergo that kind of suffering myself, should I not have the choice to have that available to me before that capacity is taken away by the disease process?

Kent MacDonald, Cardigan

Liberal
“I support this bill. It lets people ask for medical assistance in dying in advance, so people facing diseases like Alzheimer's can still make their own choice.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the whole issue of advance directives is one in which we cannot leave one group of people out. Those people who may face Alzheimer’s or some other neurological disorder they are not aware of should be able to make their own choice. That is why I support Bill C-41, which would allow a person to make an advance directive about an illness that may approach them in the future.

Garnett Genuis, Sherwood Park—Fort Saskatchewan

Conservative
“I want a clear answer to my question. Will government members be allowed to vote their conscience on this bill, or will they be forced to vote with the justice minister?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I did not really get a clear answer to my previous question, so I will follow up on it. This is a piece of government legislation. Normally on issues of conscience, historically, at least for our party, they are free votes. Are members of the government free to vote their conscience according to what they hear from their constituents, and from their own perspective, or are they going to be compelled to take the same position as the Minister of Justice?

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 165

  1. Private Members' Business Youth Criminal Justice Act 5 statements
  2. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 37 statements
  3. Government Orders Government Orders 23 statements
  4. Statements by Members Ordre National du Mérite Agricole 2 statements
  5. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  6. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  7. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  9. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 4 statements
  12. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  13. Oral Questions The Economy 10 statements
  14. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 19 statements
  16. Oral Questions Labour 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 6 statements
  18. Oral Questions Taxation 2 statements
  19. Oral Questions Committees of the House 2 statements
  20. Oral Questions Parks Canada 2 statements
  21. Government Orders Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act 95 statements
  22. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  25. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements