Translate Politics: Parliament in plain language.

Recent debates 8 latest debates

The Budget

The debate over the Budget centered on concerns regarding the government’s management of national debt, which opposition members noted reached $1.37 trillion, and overall spending. Members argued that government investments lacked productive value, citing the high cost of the Alto high-speed rail project, and claimed that current policies were unaffordable for Canadians facing rising costs for groceries and fuel. In response, the government defended the budget, stating that global economic conditions and the need to invest in the economy while maintaining a strong credit rating justified the expenditures. Opposition members also raised issues concerning agricultural funding, the accessibility of the dental plan, and the appropriateness of releasing the budget late in the fiscal year.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

10 statements

Shelby Kramp-Neuman, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga

Conservative
“I oppose this budget. People in my rural riding are struggling to afford fuel and groceries, and they do not want the government adding billions to the debt. I also want real consultation on the Alto high-speed rail project, which threatens farmland and costs too much. This government has a long history of hiding facts from the public, and it must justify every single dollar it borrows.”
  • A repeated line

    “People are struggling to make ends meet.”

    Said 14 times by 11 members since April 27.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga is home to some of Ontario’s most productive farmland, much of it worked by families for generations. It is home to small businesses that support our local economies and sustain our towns and villages. It is home to the Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte, whose history and perspectives I continue to learn from. The people I represent understand the importance of hard work and of responsible decisions. They expect the same from their government. They expect respect for their hard-earned tax dollars, a willingness to listen and accountability for the decisions that affect their lives. These are not unreasonable expectations, yet across my riding, families are struggling to make ends meet. Seniors on fixed incomes are watching their purchasing power shrink. Food banks are seeing working Canadians who never imagined they would need assistance. In rural Canada, affordability comes with challenges that, too often, Ottawa overlooks. For my constituents, driving is not a luxury. It is a necessity. It is how people get to work, attend doctor’s appointments and buy groceries. It is how farmers operate equipment and get their products to market. When fuel costs rise, those costs ripple through our economy, affecting transportation, agriculture, small businesses and ultimately the price Canadians pay for everyday necessities. When Canadians are already stretching every dollar, every additional cost matters. Those dollars matter just as much when the government decides how to spend them. Among the many concerns surrounding the government’s priorities is the Alto high-speed rail project. Residents fear losing land held by their families for generations, farmers worry about divided farmland and rural communities face disrupted access routes and lasting impacts. These are people’s homes, livelihoods and legacies. Who is listening to the people expected to make the greatest sacrifices? For the communities I represent, the Alto initiative will take rather than give. Major infrastructure projects may often offer economic opportunities but those opportunities do not excuse a government from thorough consultation, fiscal accountability or respecting the communities directly affected. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated Alto’s construction costs at between $75 billion and $113 billion-plus. That is an extraordinary financial commitment, deserving extraordinary scrutiny. This brings us to the federal budget. Budget 2026 projects a $62.3-billion deficit, with federal debt approaching $1.37 trillion and $60.2 billion in annual debt-servicing costs. That is more than $60 billion going toward interest on the debt rather than directly delivering new services to Canadians. Those annual debt charges are projected to climb to $85.5 billion by 2030–31. The families, farmers and small businesses I know and represent understand that borrowing sometimes has its place, but they also understand that every borrowed dollar must be justified. As we examine budget 2026, I believe the House must answer one crucial question. Are we making decisions that strengthen the lives of Canadians or are we asking them to carry an ever-growing financial burden without demonstrating the value they receive in return? That is the standard the people of Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga and all Canadians deserve. Next, I would like to turn to what I consider, beyond the extraordinary spending increases, the most historically significant issue in the budget, which is transparency. The manner in which the government is doing things leaves much to be desired. Only after sustained criticism did questions surrounding the Prime Minister’s relationship with Telesat receive greater scrutiny. Only after months of demands did the government disclose the companies lending employees to its Major Projects Office. Transparency should be standard operating procedure, not a crisis management strategy. Canadians are all too familiar with the government’s history on transparency, such as with WE Charity, ArriveCAN and SNC-Lavalin, names familiar to anyone who has followed politics. SNC-Lavalin was extremely troubling. The former prime minister and senior officials were found to have improperly pressured the attorney general over a prosecutorial decision, raising fundamental questions about the independence of that office and the Shawcross principle. This was hardly the first time a Liberal government faced questions about the administration of justice. In 1965, Justice Minister Guy Favreau left that portfolio following the Rivard affair after an inquiry criticized his handling of allegations involving attempted bribery and political interference. Favreau’s departure was followed by Lester B. Pearson’s recruitment of three prominent Quebec candidates, the “three wise men”: Gérard Pelletier, Jean Marchand and Pierre Elliott Trudeau. Interestingly, Favreau represented Montreal’s Papineau, a riding later represented by Pierre Trudeau’s son, Justin Trudeau, some 41 years later. Other names in Liberal Party history must not be forgotten. Groupaction Marketing, Coffin Communications, Lafleur Communication Marketing, Groupe Everest and Cockfield, Brown are names unfamiliar to newer members, perhaps, but not to those who remember the sponsorship scandal and the Gomery commission. I am sure my colleague from Bécancour—Nicolet—Saurel—Alnôbak remembers extremely well, and the member for Vancouver Centre probably wishes that she could forget. The sponsorship scandal remains one of the most consequential failures of public accountability in modern Canadian political history. In a remarkable coincidence, the Gomery hearings were held in Montreal’s Complexe Guy-Favreau. The Gomery commission’s report contained salient points that remain relevant today, which is why I am going to read a small portion of it to the House. It reads: One message has been continually emphasized in the consultations conducted by the Commission: there is a need to rebalance the relationship between Parliament and the Government. The capacity of Parliament to hold the Government to account needs to be restored and strengthened.... If the present Report succeeds in launching a public debate that leads to a rebalancing between Parliament and Government, the Commission, for that reason alone, may be considered a success. A reinforcement of the traditional role of parliamentarians would tend to restore public trust and the confidence that Canadians should have in their political and administrative institutions. That confidence is currently at a low ebb. It would contribute to a renewal of the self-esteem and sense of worth that should be felt by Members of Parliament. It would also restore the public’s respect for them. The commission’s recommendations helped shape the Federal Accountability Act introduced by the nascent Conservative government as its first piece of legislation. This legislation was not perfect, nor was the government that introduced it. As that government approached the end of its mandate, it too faced criticism over accountability and failures of communication. The institutional rot, intentional or not, is colour-blind. That is a lesson every member of the House should remember. Anyone who has walked through these halls over the past 25 years should understand the dangers that fester behind closed doors. As legislators, if we are not comfortable explaining our decisions to the Canadians we serve, we should question whether those decisions ought to be made at all. When legitimate criticism is dismissed, when accountability is avoided and when governments stop listening, the result is predictable: a culture of complacency, indifference and arrogance every single time. Ultimately, the people who pay the price are not the politicians, political staff or public servants involved. It is the taxpayer. We must never forget that everything we do in the House, every decision we make, every budget we pass and every dollar that we ultimately spend must be for them, the taxpayer, not for ourselves

Shelby Kramp-Neuman, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga

Conservative
“Canada is not in good financial shape. Our debt is $1.37 trillion, and we spend over $165 million a day just on interest. At the same time, only about two in ten Canadians can use the federal dental plan, and people contact my office with concerns about it every week.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, in response to the hon. member’s question, I am going to acknowledge a few things. The debt in our country is currently $1.37 trillion. More than $165 million is spent every single day to service the federal debt. To answer the member’s question specifically, I would have to go back, but I think it is two in 10 Canadians who are able to access the federal dental plan, so I know that our local constituency offices have a number of concerns, questions and inquiries every single week about this. Realistically, Canada needs to be financially fit, and right now we are not.

Shelby Kramp-Neuman, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga

Conservative
“Conservatives support investments that help Canada compete. But simply calling spending an investment does not make it useful. The real test is whether it creates lasting value or is just clever accounting.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, by all means, as Conservatives we welcome investment that ultimately will make Canada more competitive, but there is some confusion with how things are being labelled. Calling an expenditure an investment does not make it productive; the test really is whether it is creating lasting value and not just fitting under a creative accounting scheme.

Pat Kelly, Calgary Crowfoot

Conservative
“The Alto rail project makes no financial sense. Even if it costs $90 billion, the interest alone would be $300 per ticket, before counting running costs or paying back the original money. This project will waste money.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank the member for drawing a straight line from the Rivard affair of the Pearson era through to present Liberal corruption and the culture within that party. However, I do want to focus in my question on the Alto rail project. The member said that the PBO says it will cost probably $113 billion. I am just doing a quick bit of math. I know the project even said $90 billion. I am sure it will be much more than that, but even $90 billion at 4% interest, divided by 12 million passengers, is $300 per ticket. That is from a study from the University of Montreal. If the interest alone is $300 one way, without operating costs and without recouping capital, how could this program ever make any sense whatsoever, when it is so clearly and obviously going to be a financial boondoggle?

Shelby Kramp-Neuman, Hastings—Lennox and Addington—Tyendinaga

Conservative
“The government cannot afford the Alto train project, and Canadians do not want it. It costs too much and the numbers behind it are uncertain. The government needs to explain how people can afford gas and groceries before spending money on this.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the government 100% cannot afford it. Canadians at large do not want the Alto project. Ambition without discipline is not a national strategy, and it is an expensive promise. This Alto nonsense is an expensive promise. Canadians cannot afford a mega project built on optimistic projections with uncertain costs and completely questionable priorities. Before this government continues to bankroll the idea of Alto, I think it needs to explain to Canadians, in real dollars, about affordability, what it costs to fill one’s tank and what it costs to go to the grocery store. Alto is a non-stop, full-stop as far as I am concerned.

Lianne Rood, Middlesex—London

Conservative
“I oppose this budget. It adds too much debt, and taxpayers will pay the bill. We now pay more in interest on our debt than we send to provinces for health care. This high spending and high immigration drive up the price of food, rent, and fuel while our services fall behind. Instead of this budget, the government should cut gas taxes by 20 cents a litre, lower immigration to match our housing and health care, and cut 200 billion dollars in wasteful spending to pay down the debt.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is always a privilege to rise in this House on behalf of the residents of Middlesex—London. Every day, I hear from small business owners and families across Middlesex—London who are doing everything right and still falling behind. These people run shops, show up for the early shift and are raising kids. They keep their heads down, stay out of politics, pay their taxes without complaint, and wonder why their lives keep getting harder and why they are left with less each paycheque. Another federal budget with a multi-billion-dollar deficit has arrived and, once again, the Liberals tell us that the record spending is an investment in the future. The numbers tell a different story. This is a costly credit card budget. It is dominated by debt, and ordinary Canadians are the ones left holding the bill. The Prime Minister told Canadians that he would spend less. He said he would cut the cost of consultants. However, the reality is the exact opposite. This budget would have us broke, and spending on consultants is booming. The Prime Minister has himself warned, “A country that cannot feed itself, fuel itself, or defend itself has few options.” As record numbers of Canadians line up at food banks and families struggle with grocery bills, the Liberals are cutting Canada’s domestic agricultural research capacity. Decades of research, knowledge and ingenuity that keep food affordable and secure will be gone forever. What the Liberals are doing is not responsible. It is short-sighted and downright dangerous. As we talk about responsibility or the lack thereof, the Liberal government debt numbers are even more alarming. This budget has the government borrowing a record-smashing $765 billion over the next five years. That works out to roughly $44,000 for every household in Canada. The federal debt is already climbing to $1.37 trillion. Interest payments alone will consume $60 billion this year. That is more money than the entire Canada health transfer. That is correct. We now pay more in interest on the debt than we do to keep our crumbling health care system afloat. Let me break this down. A family of four will pay nearly $6,000 in federal debt interest costs this year alone. By 2031, that annual burden rises to $8,100 per family of four, and the total interest climbs to $85.5 billion. Every dollar spent on interest is a dollar that cannot go to nurses, doctors, defence or tax relief. The cost of putting a failed banker in charge of cooking the books in Canada is that debt servicing is no longer a footnote in the budget. It is one of the single largest items in the budget, and it keeps growing faster than almost anything else. Every additional dollar borrowed today is a burden paid through tomorrow’s taxes. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has flagged the risks. The debt-to-GDP ratio is not falling the way the Prime Minister promised during the election. It remains stuck near 40%, yet the government treats new borrowing as if it costs nothing. At the kitchen table, families are already choosing between groceries and other necessities. On the farm, higher fuel input costs, fertilizer costs and equipment costs make it harder to get food from the field to the table affordably. The lives of Canadians are not an abstract accounting exercise. The mistakes of the Liberal government drive up the costs that show up in the grocery cart and in the longer lines and empty shelves at food banks. Food prices have risen roughly 30% in the past five years. Food Banks Canada reports that monthly visits now exceed 2.3 million. That is an increase of 117% since 2019. Nearly one in five of those clients is employed. One-third of those visits are by children. Working families who never imagined needing to use a food bank are lining up. When households are already stretched thin, higher taxes and higher interest rates driven by Liberal borrowing leave them with even less room to breathe. In this budget, Canadians are also paying the price for immigration levels that far exceed our capacity to absorb them. The government’s own immigration levels plan sets a headline target of 380,000 new permanent residents. Only when the hidden side programs buried elsewhere in the budget documents are included does the real total approach 650,000. That is the highest permanent immigration level in Canadian history. That is roughly 35% above the previous record and is the equivalent of adding a city the size of Mississauga in a single year. These numbers were deliberately buried because they are indefensible. A Nanos poll found that 52% of Canadians want fewer permanent immigrants and temporary residents. High immigration makes work pay less by flooding the labour market so corporations do not have to compete for workers or raise wages. It drives up rent, which is why the CMHC expects only about 223,000 housing starts this year. It also sends more people to food banks. Newcomers now make up 31% of clients, and that is not fair to them. It pushes a broken health care system further past the breaking point, where the median wait for treatment is already 28.6 weeks. Over 23,000 Canadians died waiting for care last year. This is not compassionate immigration. Conservatives will keep fighting to bring those numbers down and in line with actual housing, health care and job capacity, so that wages can rise, rents can fall and our hospitals can recover. The government repeatedly claims its spending is an investment that will eventually pay for itself. That claim is pure fantasy in the short term and a dangerous gamble in the long term. Most of the programs being financed have not even started. They come with no clear, measurable returns. The debt costs more for those programs than what they are worth in the first place. We have become an unproductive nation. Under the Liberals it is getting worse. Investment is fleeing Canada. The promised gains in housing, clean technology and child care have not shown up at the scale or speed required to justify this borrowing. On the farm, red tape and rising costs make it harder to produce the affordable food Canadians need. If we do not support the people who grow our food, we will have less of it and pay more. Just to make this simple enough for the Liberals to understand: no farms, no food, full stop. What we continue to see from the Liberal government is more debt, higher carrying costs, endless photo opportunities and talking points that make bold claims only to be rolled back after the headlines have gone out. What the Liberal government is doing with this budget is the equivalent of someone maxing out the family credit card to buy lottery tickets and then calling it an investment strategy. Then, when they get caught, the spouse gets gaslit. There is zero accountability. A household that did that would face serious consequences quickly. The government does it and then pays the media to praise it for having ambition. Canadians cannot function on the Prime Minister’s delusions of grandeur. Good policy requires evidence that a project will make money. The evidence is missing. The accounting in this budget makes the problems Canada is experiencing worse. The Prime Minister has split spending across three separate credit cards, operational, capital and Crown corporations, with no clear, consistent rules that decide which expense belongs where. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has confirmed the absence of a defining standard. By parking billions of dollars in the capital or Crown corporation columns, the Liberals get to play pretend, so that the full cost of the borrowing does not appear in the headline deficit. If a private company did this to its investors and workers, it would face serious questions about misleading them. Taxpayers will still pay the interest, whether the government puts the borrowing on the official books or hides it off to the side. Canadians deserve transparency. They do not deserve financial engineering designed to conceal the true cost of inflationary spending. Conservatives have asked for three things to be fixed in the budget: Cut the price of gas by 20¢ a litre and by eliminating all federal taxes at the pump, cut waste, and keep the election promise to lower the debt-to-GDP ratio so that it no longer crowds out health care and other basic services. Conservatives have also put forward a practical alternative. Roughly $200 billion in savings can be found by cutting bureaucracy, consultants, foreign aid, corporate welfare and wasteful projects, such as the Alto high-speed rail boondoggle, which only enriches well-connected Liberal Party insiders. The government could bring immigration numbers back in line with the growth in housing and the availability of doctors and jobs, so that both new Canadians and those born here can succeed. It could prioritize debt reduction so the interest stops consuming more than we spend on the military or on health transfers. This cannot be said enough. To get Canada back on track, we need to focus our resources on proven measures that lower the cost of living, lower taxes, reduce red tape and bring real economic growth that creates opportunity. Hard-working families, farmers and small businesses deserve better than a budget that borrows heavily to finance claims rather than results. Conservatives will keep fighting for outcomes that benefit Canadian families. Canadians are out of money. It is time the Liberal government stopped being out of touch.

Lianne Rood, Middlesex—London

Conservative
“The Liberal government's policies have caused our current problems with health care, housing, and the cost of living. The government spends more paying its debt than it gives to provinces for health care. Our hospitals cannot handle our current population growth. I do not blame immigrants for this. I blame government spending.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the reality is that the policies of the Liberal government over the last 10 years have created the mess we have here right now. The federal debt payments are more than what we are transferring to the provinces for health care, and we are letting in more people than we have capacity for in our own hospitals right now. Len, a senior in London, says that he has watched emergency wait rooms, clinic delays and the shortage of affordable housing and senior care spaces get worse. He tells me that the cost of everyday living keeps climbing, and he worries that the quality of life that he has and that his family has built has eroded. Hubert is writing on behalf of people with disabilities and their families. He has described how the lack of timely support shows up in emergency room visits, homelessness and family breakdowns. An hon. member: Why are you blaming immigrants? Lianne Rood: Mr. Speaker, I am not blaming immigrants whatsoever. I am blaming the policies of the Liberal government and its misspending instead of focusing on Canadians.

Lianne Rood, Middlesex—London

Conservative
“I am a farmer. Liberal policies over the last ten years have hurt farmers. High taxes and tariffs on fuel and fertilizer make it too expensive to produce food. The government needs to lower taxes and create better policies to help farmers.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am in the business of agriculture, and my family has been in the business of producing food for generations. I come from a family of immigrants. I am a second-generation Canadian and a third-generation farmer. My grandparents came to this country to work hard for that promise of the Canadian dream. They worked in the tobacco fields for less than 10¢ an hour when they came to this country with nothing. Both my sets of grandparents worked their way through those tobacco fields to build the life they had, to have my parents, to have a business here in Canada and to be successful in the agriculture industry, providing food for Canadians. Unfortunately, the policies of the Liberal government for the last 10 years have done nothing but hurt farmers. The cost of production is high because of policies of the Liberal government, the cost of fuel and fertilizer and putting taxes and tariffs on fertilizer, making food less affordable to produce for Canadians. Farmers can absorb only so much of the cost, and they need to be supported by the government by lowering taxes and having better policies to help farmers.

Costas Menegakis, Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill

Conservative
“I want to ask my colleague why the government waited seven months into the year to present this budget. Most of the money has already been spent. Do businesses in her riding operate that way?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I wonder if I could impose on my colleague to give her thoughts as to why this budget is being presented in the House seven months after the fiscal year has started. Seven months of the money has already been spent, and the Liberals are bringing it in as if it were something new. I wonder if she could share with us whether businesses in her riding operate that way.

Lianne Rood, Middlesex—London

Conservative
“The government tried to hide this bad budget by releasing it late before a break week. They are spending too much, which will cost Canadians more. As a business owner, I would never release a budget this late in the year.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, when the Liberals dropped this budget on a Thursday afternoon, going right into a constituency week, it was that bad that they had to hide this budget for an entire week from Canadians. They are overspending, and they know it is going to cost Canadians more. As a business owner myself, there is no way I would have a budget this far down in my fiscal year. The government is doing nothing to help Canadians in my—

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules