The Budget

Debate on the federal budget at second reading. Liberals supported it, pointing to affordability measures such as a groceries benefit and caregiver support, housing investment, tax cuts for businesses and new homes, training for skilled trades workers, and plans to balance operating costs by 2027-28; they noted Canada’s low debt-to-GDP ratio in the G7. Conservatives opposed the budget, saying it adds hundreds of billions in spending and debt with interest costs exceeding health care spending, and argued it does nothing to fix health care wait times, shortages of doctors, hospital beds and MRI machines, or rising food bank use and cost of living. Bloc Québécois members said the budget does not increase Old Age Security pensions for those aged 65 to 74 as they had sought and questioned calling spending “investment,” also raising oil and gas subsidies. One procedural point of order concerned an accusation of dishonesty. No vote outcome is recorded here.Written by AI from the debate. Updated .

Official text (opens in a new tab)

46 statements

Peter Fonseca, Mississauga East—Cooksville

Liberal
“I want the House to pass the budget. It helps people in my riding with the cost of living. It gives millions of Canadians money for groceries, spends billions of dollars to build more homes, cuts taxes on new houses, and gives money to caregivers.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I will be sharing my time with the member for Winnipeg North. It is always an honour to rise in this House on behalf of the people of Mississauga East—Cooksville to speak about the future of our country and, more importantly, the future of the families, workers, seniors, young people and small business owners who call our community home. I rise today in support of budget 2026, “Masters of our destiny”. This is a budget about building a stronger, more independent, more affordable Canada. However, before I speak about billions of dollars in investments, economic growth or fiscal policy, I want to speak about something that is much more personal. I want to speak about the people that I represent. For the people of Mississauga East—Cooksville, this budget is not simply a collection of numbers that we will talk about; it is about their lives, and it is about their families, jobs and futures. When I am speaking with residents at community events, visiting small businesses, meeting seniors or talking to families at their doorsteps, I hear many of the same concerns. Parents are worried about the price of groceries; seniors are worried about whether their pensions will stretch far enough; young people are wondering whether they will be able to afford a home; small business owners are dealing with higher costs, global competition and uncertainty over trade with the United States; and families caring for aging parents or relatives with disabilities are asking for more support. These are not abstract economic questions; they are the everyday realities of the people we were elected to serve, and they are precisely why budget 2026 matters. I came to Canada as an immigrant from Portugal. My family came here because Canada represented an opportunity. It was a country where if someone worked hard, believed in themselves and contributed to their community, they could build a better future. I was fortunate enough to represent Canada as an Olympic athlete, and today I have the extraordinary privilege of representing Canadians in this House. I have seen first-hand what this country makes possible. Mississauga East—Cooksville reflects that Canadian story. Our riding is home to families whose roots reach across the globe from Portugal to Poland, Ukraine, Philippines, India, Pakistan, the Caribbean, Africa and many other parts of the world. We have people of different faiths, cultures and traditions, but we share something fundamental. We want our children to succeed. We want our parents and grandparents to live with dignity. We want safe neighbourhoods, good jobs, affordable homes and an economy that rewards hard work. That is the Canada I believe in, and that is the Canada that this budget is building. The first issue is affordability. I know that Canadians are still feeling the pressure of higher prices. I hear it in conversations with seniors on fixed incomes. I hear it from parents who are doing everything they can to provide for their children. I hear it from workers who are earning a paycheque, but still find themselves struggling at the end of the month. We cannot tell these families that economic growth alone will solve their problems tomorrow; we have to look at what is happening today. That is why budget 2026 introduces another one-time supplement to the Canada groceries and essentials benefit. The measure will provide a 50% increase in the benefit this 2026 benefit year, and it will come in early 2027. More than 12 million Canadians are expected to benefit. For many families, that is meaningful assistance with groceries, food and other essential expenses. We know that a benefit payment alone will not solve food inflation. We also have to address the underlying cost of food, and that is why our government is moving forward with a national food security strategy, investing in Canadian food production, processing and competition. We need more food produced and processed right here in Canada. We need stronger supply chains, and we need more competition so that Canadian families have more choice in the grocery store. This budget also strengthens support for lower-income workers through the build Canada workers benefit. This is about making sure that people who get up every morning, work so hard and contribute to our economy can keep more of what they earn. Work should provide dignity, opportunity and the ability to build a decent life. This principle must remain at the core and centre of our economic policy. One of the greatest challenges facing our communities is housing. In Mississauga East—Cooksville, many young people who grew up in our neighbourhoods want to remain close to their families. They want to begin their careers, get married, raise children and build their lives in the community they know and love, but too many feel that home ownership is slipping beyond their reach. At the same time, renters are worried about affordability, and some of our most vulnerable residents face housing insecurity and homelessness. Budget 2026 proposes approximately $44.7 billion over 11 years to support housing and homelessness measures. Our goal is to significantly increase the construction of non-market housing supply and get Canada on a path to eradicating and ending homelessness over the next decade. Housing is about more than simply putting a roof over someone’s head. I have taken a particular interest in what is called the Dunn House model, in Toronto, which demonstrates the importance of connecting supportive housing with health care and community services. It recognizes something very important. People experiencing homelessness often need more than housing alone. They may need mental health services, addiction treatment, primary health care and ongoing community support. I believe we should explore how that kind of integrative model can be expanded into Mississauga, working with our local health organizations, such as the Trillium Health Partners. A stronger Canada should be measured not only by how many homes we build, and yes, we are building homes, but also by how many people we help to regain stability, security and hope. For young families looking to buy their first home, our government is supporting measures to reduce GST on qualifying new homes. It is also working with provinces and municipalities to reduce unnecessary costs and accelerate construction. Canada needs more homes of every kind: affordable rentals, supportive housing, homes for seniors and homes that young families can actually afford. One of the greatest privileges of representing Mississauga East—Cooksville is spending time with our seniors. Many immigrants who came to this country decades ago worked in construction and in factories, built businesses, raised families and helped create the communities we enjoy today. They contributed to Canada’s prosperity. In their retirement years, they deserve security and dignity. Many Canadians are quietly caring for their aging parents, a spouse with a serious illness or a family member living with a disability. These caregivers often make enormous personal and financial sacrifices. That is why, under budget 2026, eligible caregivers could receive up to $1,260 annually. That is nearly 600,000 caregivers, and 180,000 of them were providing that care and receiving nothing prior to this budget. It will be a tremendous benefit for them. This is the kind of practical measure that can make a difference in people’s lives. I want to return to where I began, with the families of Mississauga East—Cooksville; the seniors who helped build our country; the workers who get up every morning to work hard for our country and for their families; the parents who want their children to have a better life; the small business owners who take risks, create jobs and contribute to our communities; and the young people who want to believe that opportunities available to previous generations will also be available to them. When my family came to Canada, we believed in the promise of this country that with hard work, determination and opportunity, a better future was always possible. I still believe in that promise, but maintaining that promise requires action, and that is coming through budget 2026. It requires us to build more homes, create better jobs and support our seniors. Our responsibility, all of us here in this House, whatever our partisan stripe, is to leave Canada stronger, more prosperous and more united than we found it. That is the future I want for my children and for every Canadian family, and that is why I am so proud to support budget 2026.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe, Lac-Saint-Jean

Bloc Québécois
“We should not use tax money to support the oil and gas industry. That industry causes climate change, which harms our children's future.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I listened carefully to my colleague’s speech. He concluded by saying that we are doing this for our children’s future and that we have responsibilities. I tend to agree with him. Does he understand that we in the Bloc Québécois have serious concerns about using public funds to subsidize one of the industries that contributes the most to climate change, namely the oil and gas industry? With our children’s future and our responsibilities in mind, I have a simple question for my colleague: Is it right to take public money, taxes paid by Quebeckers and Canadians, and invest it in an industry that will disrupt the climate, which will be harmful to our children’s future?

Peter Fonseca, Mississauga East—Cooksville

Liberal
“Our budget gives tax deductions to businesses. This helps them buy new equipment, create jobs, and become greener and more efficient.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 47 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I thank the member for the opportunity to speak about young people and to talk about the vision for Canada, the same covenant that was given to my parents in terms of the opportunity to succeed here in this country. The member talks about some of the different sectors we have in our country. We need businesses to succeed, and that is why we have put in the mega deduction. It is a productivity deduction, to make a company more efficient and more green. They can invest in equipment, advanced manufacturing and all of these opportunities to be able to create jobs and do it in a sustainable and green way.

Vince Gasparro, Parliamentary Secretary to the Secretary of State (Combatting Crime)

Liberal
“I want the member to explain how the caregiver tax credit would help his mother, the people in our ridings, and caregivers across Canada.”
  • Question or comment in debate

    Signal 39 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is great to be here, and it was great to listen to the hon. member specifically. He and I have known each other for quite a while. He has spent a great deal of time talking about the people of his riding but also his family, and there is a connection to Eglinton—Lawrence. His mother lives in my riding of Eglinton—Lawrence. He talked about caregivers and the caregiver tax credit. Maybe the hon. member would like to talk about how the caregiver tax credit could help his mother and people like his mother in his riding and in my riding of Eglinton—Lawrence and caregivers across the country.

Peter Fonseca, Mississauga East—Cooksville

Liberal
“I want the budget to pass. Caregivers do important work for seniors, mostly for free. This budget will give 600,000 caregivers up to $1,260 to help with their costs.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, my mom gets the hon. member’s newsletters just about every month. What she loves is the crossword. I always ask her for some of the answers to help her out. She loves those crosswords. Caregivers are unsung heroes right across our country. We know them. They are individuals from our families. They are in the neighbourhoods. They do work on behalf of seniors who need that extra support. For the most part, most are doing this all for free. They do not get any benefit. They are not getting any support. Through the budget, now 600,000 caregivers across our country, with 180,000 who never got any financial support to help with their costs, will be getting up to $1,260 to help with those caregiving supports they provide in our communities that are so essential. I know our country would not be as strong without those supports.

Warren Steinley, Regina—Lewvan

Conservative
“The news says the government is spending over $331 billion more in this budget. But the government said it would save $60 billion. I want the member to explain how both can be true.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I am just reading a headline on CTV News right now. It says the government is going to spend $331.6 billion more in this budget. I also remember that when the budget was presented, there was supposed to be $60 billion worth of savings. I am just wondering how one can spend $331.6 billion more and then save $60 billion. Could the member square that circle for me?

Peter Fonseca, Mississauga East—Cooksville

Liberal
“Our government manages money responsibly. We plan to balance our operating costs by 2027-28 so that our revenues cover them. We are also spending money on housing, infrastructure, and energy because families, businesses, and workers need those things.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I thank the member for the opportunity to talk about how paramount fiscal responsibility is to this government. That is why this government has taken an approach whereby we are going to, by 2027-28, balance the operating costs of government so revenues will be able to take care of those operating costs. I will also say to the member that we are investing in Canada. We believe in Canada. That is why we are investing in housing, in infrastructure, in energy, in public infrastructure, things that make our country better. This is what families, businesses and workers are asking for. This is what will make Canada strong.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“I support the budget. Our government is building a stronger economy by creating major projects across Canada, signing new trade deals, and attracting half a trillion dollars in investments. The budget gives tax write-offs to businesses so they can buy equipment and create jobs. It also invests billions of dollars to work with provinces, cities, and Indigenous leaders to fight homelessness.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, it is quite the pleasure to rise and speak to the budget this year. I want to frame it between the last federal election and where we are today. For me, it is all about ways we can build strength in our economy and build a better, healthier and stronger society. Virtually from day one after the last federal election, there was a great deal of concern about the direction Canada was going in, given the Trump tariffs and trade. During the election, we talked about how we needed to build one Canadian economy. Shortly after that election, we brought forward legislation to deal with just that, a one Canada economy. We demonstrated, by working with different stakeholders, in particular our leaders, indigenous leaders, provinces and territories, how, as we work together, we can actually build that one Canada economy. The federal government brought in legislation, and we did our part from a federal perspective, in anticipation that we will see more and more barriers taken down through strong provincial leadership. We know that is ultimately what Canadians want to see. Shortly thereafter, we started to talk a great deal about major projects, virtually from coast to coast to coast. We can talk about LNG in British Columbia, the MOU and the pipeline discussion taking place in Alberta, copper mines in Saskatchewan, mining in Manitoba and the potential of the Churchill port, which is something the premier talks a great deal about nowadays along with the federal government. We can talk about nuclear energy in Ontario, the port of Montreal or the many different energy projects being talked about for Atlantic Canada, not to mention what is happening in the north in mining and military investment. With all of these major projects, close to half a trillion dollars, in every region of our country, we are seeing the benefits. The Prime Minister leads a number of ministers who have been doing a lot of travelling, and that is a good thing. We have had a couple of dozen trade agreements and security agreements in the last 18 months. It is absolutely incredible to see the number of trade and security agreements. We have passed legislation: Northern Ireland, England, Indonesia. I am very proud of how, as a government, we moved so quickly on a trade agreement with the Philippines. In fact, I believe it was just last July 3 when we had a discussion, and I was grateful to be a part of that discussion, with President Marcos and the Prime Minister of Canada sitting down in Vancouver and saying they wanted to achieve a trade agreement. In just these last few days, we have achieved that trade agreement. Later this year, we are hoping to see another trade agreement, with India. All of that is so critically important. It is how we expand trade opportunities beyond Canada-U.S.A. trade. It is not to take anything away from the trade we do with the United States. It is about our sovereignty and ensuring that we have more opportunities that go beyond the Canada-U.S.A. border, and we have seen incredible movement on that front. We had the Prime Minister talk a great deal about investment, not only in terms of public dollars coming from different levels of government, but also private dollars. Members can take a look at what was taking place in September, where we had the Prime Minister host the world in regard to investing in Canada. The response that we got was absolutely unheard of in historical amounts of dollars. We are talking about half a trillion dollars that companies and individuals in many sectors of society are now looking at Canada in terms of investing. That is unheard of, not to mention the billions of dollars that were acquired and committed even prior to that. Then we can take a look at the whole bigger picture fitting into the budget. That brings me to the Canada productivity mega deduction. That is a significant aspect of the budget. It is a continuation of everything that I have been talking about already in my comments. It is about building a stronger and healthier Canadian economy that works for all Canadians. That deduction will provide businesses, small, medium and large alike, with the opportunity to write off capital and other types of equipment. That is going to, ultimately, increase productivity and create jobs. I had the opportunity to provide comment and detail on that just last Friday, when I was at the Fort Garry fire truck manufacturing plant that has been in existence in Winnipeg now for over 100 years, since 1919. The best fire trucks in the world are manufactured in the northwest end of Winnipeg. Whether it is used by well-established companies like Fort Garry fire truck or those newer companies that are popping up throughout our nation, that particular deduction is going to allow a company to ultimately write off certain things that would enable the expansion of production. When we see that, what we are really talking about is not only a question of modernization, but also expansion. By doing that, what we are talking about is jobs. Every initiative I have mentioned so far contributes to a stronger, healthier economy and building more jobs. On the other side, because it was raised earlier today, there is the issue of homelessness. The day after the budget was presented in the House of Commons, the Prime Minister was in Winnipeg to talk about that issue. It is a multi-billion-dollar commitment over a number of years. What was really quite impressive was the fact that when we were there making the announcement, we had the Prime Minister centre-front with the Premier of Manitoba and the Mayor of Winnipeg, demonstrating the will and desire of all levels of government to take on that issue, including indigenous leaders. This government made a powerful statement the day after the budget, working in collaboration, because there is no way any level of government is going to be able to do that on its own. It is going to take collaboration. Through the strong leadership of our Prime Minister, working with the provinces that are willing, like Manitoba, and Winnipeg, and indigenous communities, we are making a difference. I am very proud of the fact that Winnipeg is actually leading the way, I would suggest to colleagues, in dealing with the issue of homelessness, because it goes far beyond just not having a home. It deals with issues of mental health, addictions and so many other things.

Burton Bailey, Red Deer

Conservative
“This budget adds 765 billion dollars to the national debt. Interest on the debt now costs more than health care. The government is also bringing in hundreds of thousands of new residents while young Canadians cannot afford homes.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, this Liberal costly budget is adding $765 billion in spending to the national debt. If Canadians thought Justin Trudeau knew how to throw money around, the current Prime Minister looks like he is from a different dimension. Debt interest charges are the fastest-growing budget item, more than health care. Why is the Liberal government accelerating residency for hundreds of thousands of people while young Canadians and families still cannot afford a home in cities where most of these arrivals settle?

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“The Conservatives are misleading people about immigration. It is not true that the government plans to bring in more than 600,000 immigrants. These false claims cause harm and fuel racism. Immigrants have helped build Canada, and the Conservatives need to be honest about the facts.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 14 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I find it somewhat distasteful the manner in which the Conservative Party of Canada is dealing with the issue of immigration. I would like to emphasize the misleading information, whether from the Conservative Leader or other Conservative members, in an attempt to give the false impression that the government is going to be bringing 600,000-plus immigrants into Canada. That is just not true. They had better wake up and realize the damage that is caused when they make assertions of that nature. I would suggest they need to be more honest when trying to portray the reality of the situation. If they were, racism and so many other issues would not be at the boiling point they are at in certain areas of our nation. At the end of the day, immigrants have built this nation working with Canadians.

Roman Baber, North York

Conservative
“The member accused us of being dishonest. Our rules do not allow that. I want him to take back what he said.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I rise on a point of order. I believe it is against the Standing Orders to accuse other members of dishonesty. I would kindly ask the member, and I say this as an immigrant to Canada, who spoke of racism, to please withdraw the allegation of dishonesty.

Luc Thériault, Montcalm

Bloc Québécois
“Health care is the top priority for people in Quebec, but the federal government only pays 21 cents of every dollar spent on it. Health care costs go up five to six percent a year, but federal funding will only increase by three percent. I want to know why the government gives one-time money instead of stable, long-term funding so we can hire workers and prevent illness.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, one of the things that sets Canada apart from the United States is our health care legislation. Since the Prime Minister took office, however, health care has not been a priority, even though it is the top priority for Quebeckers. My colleague talked about homelessness. Homelessness is a complex phenomenon that involves multiple types of interventions from social services and health services. Why is the government giving with one hand but taking away with the other? The health transfer escalator is currently set to come back down to 3%, yet system costs are between 5% and 6% per year. In the wake of the pandemic, why has only $46 billion in new money been invested over 10 years? My colleague will likely reply with some big numbers, but at the end of the day, this government is only paying 21¢ of every dollar spent on health care. How does the government expect us to shift from curing to preventing? That will require people working in mental health, people who can provide predictability in the health care system. Why is this government not injecting sustainable funding? It simply injects funds on a piecemeal basis, on an ad hoc basis.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“The member is wrong to say our government is not supporting health care. We continue to fund health transfers. We just gave almost $200 million to Manitoba for an addiction treatment centre, and we are spending billions more on hospital buildings and emergency care.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I believe the good news is that the federal government continues to support the health care transfers that are absolutely necessary. That funding formula is something that has been well-established over a number of years. Where I would correct the member is when he tries to give an impression that the current Prime Minister and the government are not supporting health care. I made reference to him coming to Winnipeg the day after the budget. There was a commitment of just under $200 million. The premier stood up to say how great that $200 million was because it was going to assist in making sure we get a hospital of sorts to deal with the issue of addictions, and so much more. In addition to that, we are investing literally billions over the next few years in capital infrastructure. I am hoping that the Seven Oaks hospital’s emergency services is going to be a major beneficiary. I believe it will be. We will see $1.75 million going towards it. We have not given up on health care at all.

Élisabeth Brière, Sherbrooke

Liberal
“People in Canada should not have to sleep outside in the winter. I want my colleague to explain how the budget helps homeless people find housing.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, two weeks ago, I visited Estrie Aide in my riding for a special event called “orphaned socks”. I saw people choosing hats, gloves, boots, warm clothes and socks, of course, to get prepared for winter. It is hard to accept that in a country like Canada people will sleep outside this winter. I would like to hear from my colleague how the measures announced in the budget will make sure that Stéphane, for example, will have a roof over his head.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“The government has many programs to help Canadians. One example is the grocery benefit, which gives people money to help with food and basic needs.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 48 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I appreciate how close the member is to her community. There are many different benefits. A good example would be the groceries and essentials benefit program, which is there to put money in Canadians’ pockets. We continue to see that increased.

Melissa Lantsman, Thornhill

Conservative
“I am voting against the budget, and I want other members to vote against it too. The government got an extra 158 billion dollars from higher oil prices and inflation, but it is spending almost all of it instead of paying down debt. Because of this, Canada will borrow hundreds of billions more dollars. Soon we will spend more money on debt interest than on health care. This reckless spending makes life harder and more expensive for Canadians.”
  • A repeated line

    “A former governor of the Bank of Canada.”

    Said 8 times by 8 members since April 28.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I am going to split my time with the hon. member for Kildonan—St. Paul. Members of Parliament spend a lot of time on the road, and sometimes there is a spare moment here and there at an airport or in an Uber or when grabbing dinner. When that happens, like most people, most normal people, I find myself mindlessly scrolling through Instagram, because members of Parliament are normal people too. There is this guy who came across my feed. His name is Dave Ramsey. He keeps coming up on my feed. Members might have heard of him or might have seen him. He is a radio host who gives financial advice to random people who call in to his show. The calls normally go something like this. The person says they live paycheque to paycheque and have a boatload of debt, but they just got a big inheritance from this rich uncle of theirs who died. Dave nods along, because he sees where this is going. Then the caller says they are thinking they should buy a Ferrari. This makes for good entertainment, because we see the look on Dave’s face at the utter foolishness of this person who wants to blow their inheritance on a fancy car, when obviously they should be using it to pay down their debt. I think I should call in to the show next time and tell them about this place called Canada, a state of successive Liberal budgets that over and over again blow the inheritance on a fancy car. The government just did that. It just came into a bunch of money, $158 billion more than expected this spring. The inheritance came from a rich uncle named higher oil prices and higher inflation. The Liberals just told us here in this budget they tabled in the House less than two weeks ago that they are going to spend 96% of that entire windfall. This means 96¢ of every single dollar will go towards buying a new bright red Ferrari complete with all of the bells and whistles instead of doing the responsible thing Dave would tell us to do, which is pay down some of that debt. Had they banked that windfall, the deficits over the next five years would have been cut roughly in half, from about $289 billion to about $137 billion. These are still eye-popping numbers. Instead, they came down by just $7 billion. I will tell the House why this matters. The Prime Minister likes to present himself as a careful steward of the public purse. I think that is why Canadians elected him. He is a former central banker, a numbers man, but the numbers in the budget tell a very different story. This is not a budget of a fiscal conservative, despite what he wants us to think. This is his second budget, and he cannot blame a minority Parliament anymore. He has the majority. He has a free hand and he can use it to borrow and spend more, which is exactly what he did. All of those who are watching this from Bay Street who thought maybe he was a fiscal conservative, maybe he was a responsible manager of the purse, are seeing right through this. The deficit this year is $62.3 billion with no return to balance anywhere even in a plan, not next year and not even by the end of the decade. Even that number flatters the government. More and more spending is being moved off the main books into Crown corporations and into funds. This includes a $25-billion sovereign wealth fund funded entirely by borrowed money. It is like a family telling the bank that the budget is balanced while starting a secret renovation on a credit card that is from another bank. This is what is going on in Canada and that is why Ottawa will borrow $765 billion in new cash over the next five years. The Parliamentary Budget Officer said that today. Net debt will rise from $1.45 trillion this year to $1.92 trillion by 2031. This is important because debt is not free. Until we pay it back, we pay interest on it. Last year, that interest bill was $53.5 billion and by 2031, it will be $85.5 billion, an increase of 60%. Let me put that in human terms. By the end of this plan, Ottawa will spend more than $5,000 a year for every household in Canada on interest, and that total is going up to $8,000 a year by 2031. That is a couple of months’ worth of rent. That is a new furnace. That is a whole year of RESP contributions for a family. It could have paid for hospitals, it could have paid for schools, and it could have paid for equipment for the armed forces, but it did not. It just pays for interest. It is the fastest-growing line item in the budget. Instead, it goes to bondholders and buys nothing. Here is a fact that every Canadian should know about when they look at this budget. Starting this year, Ottawa will spend more on interest than it sends to the provinces in the Canada health transfer. That means that a Canadian family spends more on the interest on the debt than the government spends on providing health care for Canadians across the country. Today, about 10¢ of every federal revenue dollar goes to interest. By 2031, the same date I have been talking about, it will be almost 14¢. Interest on the debt is the fastest-growing line item within the budget. It is growing faster than health care, faster than transfers to the provinces for anything else and faster than any program that the government puts forward. It is not health care, it is not seniors and it is not defence. These are not my numbers. That is what I want everyone to know. These are the numbers right from the Liberal budget that was presented in this House. People will probably remember the name David Dodge. I am sure the Prime Minister does. He is a former Governor of the Bank of Canada, just like the Prime Minister. He warned us that once debt servicing, which is the money that we pay down on the debt, passes 10¢ on the dollar, the debt becomes unsustainable, and borrowing gets too expensive. The Prime Minister is now taking us to 14¢ on the dollar. That is 40% past the benchmark that his predecessor at the Bank talked about. We know the budget is a statement of priorities. We get that. We just do not see that Canadians were prioritized in this budget. It shows Canadians what the Canadian government values when choices get hard. The government’s priorities seem to be very clear in this budget: more spending, more borrowing and more debt for Canadians. Canadians are living with very different priorities. Grocery bills are higher. Rent is still climbing in most cities in this country. Families are reviewing their mortgages and are facing bigger payments, while interest rates continue to climb. Canadians, every day in their homes, are doing exactly what the government will not. They are making hard choices and living within their means. All we are asking is for the government to do the same thing. When families are stretched thin, the last thing they need is a government adding billions more in borrowing, which puts more pressure on prices, on interest rates and eventually on mortgage renewals. The government’s main answer on affordability is a modest grocery rebate. That is a drop in the bucket next to a paycheque that stopped covering those essentials a long time ago. Here is the bottom line: If Canadians are trying to make ends meet in this country, if they are trying to fill their tanks to get to work, if they are trying to save a little to get ahead or take a small vacation once every year or once every couple of years, this budget is not for them. It is for the government. There is nothing in here for Canadians. Canadians’ tax dollars go to interest instead of to the services that they rely on. Maybe that does not mean anything to them today, but it will certainly mean something to them tomorrow, the day after and for a generation into the future, when our grandchildren and our children will pay for these decisions that they had no say in. I started with Dave Ramsey, the guy whose videos I had been scrolling through, and I will end with him. When a caller asks about the Ferrari, Dave does not laugh for long. He knows that the car loses value the minute it leaves the lot. While debt and interest keep growing, his advice never changes. He says to use the windfall to get out of debt and get one’s house in order in case something happens. This is not an ideology. It is the responsible thing for governments to do. Canadian families do it at their kitchen tables every day. The government got an inheritance. It got a windfall, and it spent the whole pie. If the Prime Minister called that show, Dave would tell him the exact same thing: Do not buy the car. Pay down the debt. Do it for future generations. For those reasons, I am voting against this budget, and I hope members opposite will too.

Vince Gasparro, Parliamentary Secretary to the Secretary of State (Combatting Crime)

Liberal

Linked statement

“Our budget invests in projects that build things and create good jobs. For example, our $10 billion for the Churchill Falls project will create 23,000 jobs. I want the member to admit that investing is different from just spending.”
  • A repeated line

    “The largest investment in renewable energy in North American history.”

    Said 4 times by 3 members since October 6.

    Every time it was said
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I listened intently to my hon. colleague. She knows I have a great deal of respect for her. This budget and this government spend a great deal of time talking about investment, like investment in infrastructure and investment in productive assets that create long-term, good-paying jobs. We can look at Churchill Falls, where 23,000 jobs are being created because of the Government of Canada’s $10 billion in financing for that project. It is the largest renewable energy project in North American history. Does my hon. colleague agree that there is a fundamental difference between spending and investing?

Melissa Lantsman, Thornhill

Conservative
“The government is fudging its spending numbers. The budget officer said $135 billion the government calls capital investment is not capital at all. I want the member to present accurate numbers that the budget officer can verify.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, of course we agree. Every Canadian agrees. It is just that the government does not understand the difference, and just today, the Parliamentary Budget Officer, whom they themselves hired, talked about $135 billion that the government called capital investment but is not capital at all. The government is fudging the numbers, so I invite my hon. colleague to at least table numbers that are accurate and that the Parliamentary Budget Officer can actually discern.

Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe, Lac-Saint-Jean

Bloc Québécois
“The member is right that this spending is not an investment. The government gives too much money to the oil and gas industry, which does not need it. The industry makes record profits and is mostly owned by Americans. I want to know if the member agrees that we should end these subsidies and give the money back to Canadians and Quebeckers.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I really loved my colleague’s last answer. She is absolutely right. There is a significant difference between what the Liberals call an investment and what is, in reality, spending. She is correct on that point, and the Parliamentary Budget Officer has said as much. Once again, her response was both accurate and on point. There is another issue on which I suspect my colleague and I may agree, because her leader has spoken about it repeatedly. He calls it corporate welfare. The government continues to provide subsidies to industries that do not need the money. I am referring to the oil and gas industry. We are talking about an industry that is posting record profits, that is one of the few sectors largely unaffected by tariffs, that is 60% American-owned and that sells 90% of its products to the United States. However, it is the economic sector that receives the most support from this government, financed by the tax dollars of Canadians and Quebeckers. Would my colleague not agree that these subsidies should be scrapped and the money should be returned to Quebeckers and Canadians?

Melissa Lantsman, Thornhill

Conservative
“The government needs to stop giving handouts to corporations. When the government spends all the money, private businesses do not invest here. The government claimed 500 billion dollars is coming in from an investment summit. But the budget watchdog and the government's own budget show none of that money is tied to real projects. It is all smoke and mirrors.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 31 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I love the sound of the Bloc Québécois finally agreeing that corporate welfare in this country needs to come to an end, but there is a bigger problem here. When the government has all the cash, when private capital is not put to work here and when companies do not see an investment climate that they can invest in, the government ends up with all of the money. The problem is that industries rely on those handouts before the government ever criticizes or speaks out against an industry. The government House leader stood here and talked about $500 billion coming into an investment summit. Today, this Parliamentary Budget Officer and the Liberals’ own budget say that none of that is attached to a single project. The problem with getting investment is that we have to have a project or we have to have an item that the investment can go to, and none of that is clear. This is all smoke and mirrors, and soon Canadians will realize that.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 166

  1. Government Orders The Budget 87 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 8 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 4 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Economy 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 11 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Budget 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions International Trade 13 statements
  8. Oral Questions The Economy 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 11 statements
  10. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Rail Transportation 6 statements
  12. Oral Questions The Budget 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Rail Transportation 2 statements
  14. Oral Questions Telecommunications 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Forestry Industry 4 statements
  16. Oral Questions Housing 2 statements
  17. Government Orders The Budget 46 statements
  18. Oral Questions Justice 4 statements
  19. Oral Questions Employment 4 statements
  20. Private Members' Business Fair Representation Act 3 statements
  21. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  22. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  23. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  24. Private Members' Business Fair Representation Act 2 statements