MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT

Mandy Gull-Masty

Follow by RSS

As Minister of Indigenous Services, Gull-Masty is pushing Bill C-37, the First Nations Clean Water Act, and defends the spending behind it, including $4.6 billion for drinking water and $8.5 billion for child and family services. Her commitments often come without a date, measure or named actor: “We are working on this law in partnership with those very communities.” She speaks often of doing the work together with First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities.Written by AI from their statements. Updated .

Average grade
B
79 / 100 over 20 statements
Signal 75 / 100
Relevance 71 / 100
Respect 100 / 100
Clarity 83 / 100
Averaged over the 20 of 22 statements graded so far.

In their own words

Loses points more than most for

Loses points less than most for Talking about something other than the matter at hand: the question asked, or the bill, motion or speech under debate.Less often than most members.What the tags mean

Statements 22

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Terry Sheehan

“I want to congratulate the Saskatoon Tribal Council on reclaiming control over their children's care. A new agreement will provide them $269 million over seven years for housing, prevention, and support services.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to first sincerely congratulate Tribal Chief Arkan and the Saskatoon Tribal Council on a historic milestone, reclaiming what has always been theirs: the authority to make decisions for their children. This landmark regional agreement, Māmowōhkamātowin, will see $269 million deployed over seven years, which will put predictable, flexible funding where communities need it the most. Investing in prevention, housing, post-majority supports and first nations representative services, we proudly—

Government Orders ·

First Nations Clean Water Act

In response to a question from Kevin Lamoureux

“I want this bill to pass. It gives First Nations the power, jurisdiction, and funding to manage their own water and protect their environment. Many communities in places like Manitoba and northern Ontario badly need these resources.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 44 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, we have to take into consideration that the work we do here is not only about water system infrastructure but also about giving communities the power, the resource and the jurisdiction over deciding how they are going to access that. It is not only about how they are doing the work to harmonize their relationship with their environment, protect necessary resources and practise their indigenous way of life to be able to provide a service in community, but also about ensuring that we give them the resources to be successful in that space. Manitoba has been one of the provinces where we have seen an immense need. It is the same thing in northern Ontario. We have many communities across the country that are waiting for the resource in this bill to action and service their members.

In response to a question from Ellis Ross

“I want this bill passed. There are 38 communities waiting for clean water, including Kashechewan, which had to evacuate this year because its water system broke down. We worked with these communities on this law so children can drink safe water from their taps.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to remind my colleague that, while he speaks of big, shiny announcements, there are 38 communities waiting for this work to be done, such as Kashechewan, which this year had to evacuate because of major infiltration in its water system. There are communities hoping to do this work, and they need this valuable resource. We are working on this law in partnership with those very communities. They are waiting for the resource to be sure that their members, the children who play on their streets, can go home, turn on the tap and drink a glass of water. That is what is important. That is what we are delivering with the work we have done here.

In response to a question from Sébastien Lemire

“First Nations spent six years working on this clean water bill. It lets communities decide where to start and work with the government to build water systems that fit their needs.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, this bill is the result of six years of work by the first nations themselves. The information was provided by the communities themselves. I really took the time to study all of the evidence presented and to talk to many people who are affected by the current advisories. One of the things my colleague really needs to try to understand is that the gradual implementation of the right to access drinking water is set out in the legislation. This gives the communities the opportunity to say where they want to start and present their situation. The government will work with them to establish a water system, infrastructure and a plan that can be shared with the members of each first nation, each community, in a way that respects their circumstances.

In response to a question from Billy Morin

“Every First Nations community I met with this year supports this work and wants these tools. I want the member to work with me to support them.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
  • Reply to a debate question

    Clarity 40 of 100

    Much of this statement used imprecise wording, lacked details on timing or responsibility, or made broad claims without support.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I want to inform my colleague that, in government, we have to do the work of responding and ensuring that the government fully represents all of the positions that are presented to it, and while we do this incredible work, we are also making decisions to ensure that the historic investment that we have put forward in this space will meet their needs. Every community that has met with me this year has spoken to me about how they want to undertake this work. They support this position, and I hope that my colleague will make sure that he creates that pathway alongside me to be sure that we can offer them those tools.

In response to a question from Karim Bardeesy

“This bill gives First Nations communities the same basic clean water standards that other communities already have. It also helps First Nations set even higher standards for themselves if they want to.”
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, Bill C-37 is seeking, first and foremost, to establish the minimum standards that are in place for many residents in ridings that are not first nations communities. This is the base. If first nations communities want to do the additional work to define what that standard should be for them, they are able to do that, and we would support them through Bill C-37.

In response to a question from Sébastien Lemire

“I support this bill. I talked to communities about it. It gives them the money they need for essentials and to end boil water advisories.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 48 of 100

    None of this reply addressed the specific point raised or the topic under debate.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, I took the time to study things and speak with the communities. One very important aspect of this bill is the government’s historic investment to ensure that the communities benefiting from this bill have all the essentials, including funds to invest in the work involved in lifting boil water advisories.

In response to a question from Billy Morin

“I want my colleague to vote for this bill. Our government has already lifted many boil water advisories, and this bill will help end the 38 that remain.”
  • Reply to a debate question

    Relevance 100 of 100

    Of this reply, 100% addressed the question or point raised.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Madam Speaker, the objective of this law is to do that. I want to remind my colleague that it is the Liberal government that put forward this promise. We have done intense capital project planning, invested in community, lifted a number of boil water advisories and prevented a number of boil water advisories. Now we seek to target the 38 remaining boil water advisories. I hope that my colleague will vote for the bill so that the communities waiting for this will be able to complete the remaining work.

“I want the House to pass this bill and send it to committee. It recognizes that First Nations have the right to control their own water and wastewater. It also sets clean water standards, protects water sources, and secures long-term funding so all First Nations communities have safe drinking water.”
Official Hansard

moved that Bill C-37, An Act respecting water, source water, drinking water, wastewater and related infrastructure on First Nation lands, be read the second time and referred to a committee. She said: Madam Speaker, waachiyeh, meesuuyeh, kwe, ulaakut, tansi and hello. I rise today as a proud eeyou iskwew from the community of Waswanipi, and also as the Minister of Indigenous Services, to speak to Bill C-37, the first nations clean water act. I understand first-hand the importance of protecting water in our communities, and I understand the impact of losing it. I grew up in a nation where water was never something to take for granted. Whenever we needed fresh water, I remember being sent with a small pot to collect it and bring it back to our camp. This was a communal responsibility, and carrying water for my grandmother was simply part of daily life. That water gave her what she needed to make sure that she was able to cook, clean and sometimes even bathe babies. From that, I learned very early on that water is much more than a resource. It is something to respect, protect and take care of. It connects us to one another, to our families and to the earth. That is why, as minister, ensuring access to clean and safe drinking water is one of my highest priorities. No parent should have to question whether the water coming from their tap is safe to drink. No child should have to grow up believing that clean water is something they may not have, yet for far too many families, this has been a reality for far too long in communities. I am therefore rising today in support of Bill C-37, the first nations clean water act, which I had the honour of introducing earlier this year. The bill before us would establish a lasting framework to protect and recognize first nations jurisdiction and ensure that the resources needed are there to sustain safe water for future generations. The main purpose of this bill is to create an environment where children can safely drink tap water, where families can trust the quality of water in their homes and where communities get the opportunities they deserve. To achieve the critical goal of Bill C-37, we are proposing a robust plan that empowers first nations with tools, authority and the support to protect water in their communities and build systems that are going to serve generations to come. Across Canada, laws and regulations set strong minimum standards for drinking water, yet for far too long, first nations communities have been left without the same protections. That is unacceptable. Bill C-37 is designed to change that. It would establish a legislative framework with enforceable protections for safe drinking water that reflect first nations priorities. It would establish national principles and minimum standards. It would ensure that drinking water standards meet, at a minimum, the guidelines for Canadian drinking water quality. The bill is about much more than setting standards. It is about protecting water, recognizing first nations authority, supporting communities and ensuring that governments are accountable for the work that must continue. Rights holders have been clear and have told us that communities know what they need and they should have the authority, tools and resources to protect the water that they depend on. Bill C-37 would recognize and affirm that first nations’ inherent right to self-government includes jurisdiction over water, source water, drinking water, waste water and related infrastructure in and under first nations lands. It also seeks to help first nations develop their own approaches to water governance based on the knowledge of elders, leaders, technicians, engineers and youth. This is a fundamental part of the bill. This legislation establishes clear standards for safe drinking water, while recognizing that first nations must play a key role in decisions concerning water governance in their communities. It gives first nations the tools they need to develop and enforce their own laws and to make decisions in the best interests of their members. This is what self-determination is all about. The legislation would also establish lasting obligations. It would create accountability, clarify responsibility and bind future governments to the duty of working with first nations to advance access to clean water. We know that there is more work to do. We are continuing to do that work with first nations, but we should also recognize what has been accomplished by first nations-led solutions. This progress has only been made possible with their involvement. Together, we have lifted 157 long-term drinking water advisories. We have prevented more than 335 short-term advisories from becoming long-term. As a result of these lifts, more than 10,000 homes and over 700 community buildings, such as schools and health centres, now have access to clean drinking water. Today, nearly 80% of long-term drinking water advisories have been lifted, and this progress matters. This progress means that children who were waiting for clean drinking water can now count on the water coming out of their taps and can have access to great things for the future in terms of the systems put in place for the community. Our responsibility now is to build on that progress to eliminate the advisories that are still in place, prevent new advisories where possible and ensure that the systems we put in place today remain safe and reliable for generations to come. However, 38 long-term water advisories remain in effect in 36 communities. It is a reminder that our work is not over. It is still ongoing. Despite the progress that has been made, we realize we still have 38 advisories too many. That confirms the need for sustained efforts and long-term solutions. For many years, first nations have called for change. They have called for legislation that follows their direction and respects self-determination, legislation that recognizes their role as stewards of water, establishes clear standards and reflects the realities of their communities. Those calls have been steady and they have guided this work. Bill C-37 answers those calls. Progress like this does not happen on its own. It requires sustained investment and partnership with first nations. In June, we were able to announce $4.6 billion over five years to support water and waste-water initiatives in first nations communities, the largest investment a Canadian government has ever made in first nations water. This builds on the additional $2.3 billion provided in our government’s budget announced in 2025, as well as the $7.1 billion from 2015 to 2024. So far with these investments, since I was appointed, we have supported more than 1,700 water and waste-water projects in nearly 600 communities, helping meet the needs of almost half a million people in this country. This funding will continue to build, operate, maintain and upgrade the systems that families rely on every single day. These investments will also help support communities that are facing vastly different realities. Not all communities are starting from the same starting point. Communities need to be able to plan. They need to know that when they build infrastructure, they will have the necessary resources to maintain it. Bill C-37 would commit the federal government to working with first nations to co-develop a long-term funding framework so that decisions about water and waste-water funding are not made in isolation from the communities that are affected by them. Every community has a different reality, and every family deserves a water system they can rely on. The funding framework would also reflect the full picture of what communities need for safe drinking water. This includes infrastructure, operations, maintenance, operator training, retention, and the long-term supports needed for water systems and the people who must operate them every day. Communities know what they need, and Bill C-37 has been shaped and guided by the decisions they have made concerning water. Safe drinking water does not just begin at the tap. It also begins at the source: in the rivers, lakes, wetlands and groundwater systems that first nations have been protecting since time immemorial. For generations, first nations have known that protecting water is more than just an environmental responsibility. It is also a responsibility towards the community, culture and future generations. That is why Bill C-37 includes provisions to protect water sources by establishing protection zones that will be developed jointly with first nations, the provinces, the territories and federal partners. Through the pathway to mutually agreed upon protection zones set out in this legislation, first nations, provinces, territories and the federal government would work together to protect critical shared water resources. The bill also affirms that the first nations’ inherent right to self-government includes jurisdiction to protect water in and under their lands. I would also like to make one thing clear: Passing this bill does not mean that drinking water advisories will become a thing of the past. Water systems are dynamic. Infrastructure ages. Weather events happen. Climate change is affecting communities across the country, and unforeseen challenges can arise, even in the best-managed systems. This bill establishes a more robust legislative framework to address these challenges. It fosters continuous improvement, strengthens partnerships, provides more predictable funding and clarifies responsibilities, ensuring that communities have the resources they need to resolve problems quickly and can take the necessary steps to serve the best interests of their members. This legislation reflects Canada’s commitment to realizing the human right to safe drinking water on first nations lands. This commitment means taking action and making concrete steps to improve access to safe and clean drinking water on first nations lands. As I mentioned before, not every community is starting from the same place. Many communities have strong systems in place, while others face greater infrastructure capacity needs and operational challenges and need necessary support. Bill C-37 recognizes all those different realities. It would help communities move forward from where they are today and would support long-term progress toward safe and reliable drinking water. This is our government’s commitment through this legislation, and it is an obligation we will pass on to all future governments. Bill C-37 also proposes the creation of a first nations-led water commission. This commission would serve as a centre of expertise to support and implement the act. Its mandate, structure and services would be defined by first nations. Across the country, first nations are already leading in water stewardship. Water operators, technicians and community leaders are protecting source water, operating systems, restoring watersheds and sharing knowledge with the next generation. This bill would recognize that leadership and build on it. The proposed water commission aligns with that approach. The commission would be a first nations-led centre of expertise where communities can share knowledge, technical advice and best practices. Bill C-37 will help strengthen this resource so that communities can continue to support one another for many years to come. First nations leadership across the country has shared their stories with me about water since my appointment. These stories are of persistence, leadership and hope. I cannot help but think of those communities, where families have lived under boil water advisories for years. Access to safe drinking water will depend entirely on the work we do together. I think of children who grow up without knowing what it means to simply turn on the tap and drink. I think of that moment when change happens: when a parent no longer has to question the water, a grandmother can fill the kettle without hesitation and a child can drink freely from the tap. That is what progress looks like, and that is what we are working towards. I think of Northwest Angle No. 33 first nation in Ontario, where families lived for 12 years under a boil water advisory that was finally lifted, and where the return of safe water meant trusting the tap again in daily life. I think of Bonaparte First Nation in British Columbia, where children who have never known anything else could finally drink from the tap after more than 14 years. I think of Star Blanket Cree Nation in Saskatchewan, whose dedication and commitment to providing clean and safe drinking water helped lift a boil water advisory that had been in place since 2007. The opening of a new water treatment plant brought a 17-year advisory to an end, marking a meaningful milestone for the community. This legislation reflects more than six years of consultation and engagement with first nations leaders, technicians, water operators and communities across the country. It carries forward what first nations have told us, which is that solutions must be built together. We have made real progress since 2015, including lifting 156 long-term boil water advisories, preventing more than 335 further advisories from becoming long-term advisories, and supporting over 1,700 projects in nearly 600 communities. We still have a lot of work to do, and we need to get started right away. I believe we have an opportunity before us today. We have an opportunity to close the long-standing legislative gap, to recognize first nations jurisdiction over water and to strengthen source water protection. It is also an opportunity to create accountability in a sustainable funding framework. It is an opportunity to strengthen first nations-led governance and put historic resources to work for them. I am here to work with and for first nations that want to build this reality together. My journey as a mother, a leader and a member of my nation has shown me that real progress comes from doing things right, building trust, sharing responsibility and listening to the voices that guide our work and turning it into action. Today we have the opportunity to do exactly that. I ask all members of the House to support Bill C-37. We need to move this bill forward and continue to work in partnership with first nations. Let us build a future where every child and community can turn on the tap with confidence, and where every first nations community has the authority, resources and protections it needs to sustain clean, safe and reliable drinking water.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Doug Eyolfson

“Our government is working as full partners with Indigenous communities. We are reforming family services and improving drinking water, health care, and education. We are also supporting an Inuit-led university, fighting tuberculosis, and helping families get enough food.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, reconciliation means working in full partnership with indigenous communities. We are doing that work by advancing child and family services reform and working on clean drinking water, health care and education. This includes supporting Canada’s first Inuit-led university and also doing the critical work on tuberculosis elimination and strengthening food security for children and families across this country. This is our enduring commitment to reconciliation and the calls to action. This is what we recognize on September 30 and every day after that.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Leah Gazan

“I introduced the water bill to give communities $4.6 billion for clean drinking water. I want the member to support our work so these communities can get clean water.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 29 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it was a pleasure and an honour to introduce the water bill, because we know that the $4.6 billion of resources attached to that bill are going to help communities do the work that they need to do in community, supporting their members with clean drinking water. It was a pleasure to meet with Chief Ackabee and Chief Fisher to speak about their file. If this member wants to do meaningful work in helping those communities, she should support the meaningful collaboration that we need to do to push communities forward to have access to clean drinking water.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Leah Gazan

“First Nations need to set their own water standards, both on their lands and beyond. They also need to work with the provinces and territories to do this. For the first time, our government has partnered with them to make that happen. We will keep supporting them in this work.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am happy that my colleague has asked that question. It is one of great importance, because we know that first nations have to do the work of expanding the minimum standards that are now applicable in their communities and setting the regulatory gaps for in communities and out of communities, working, negotiating and collaborating in partnership with provincial and territorial governments. For the first time ever, this government has been able to secure that in collaboration. We will support them in community and out, in partnership, at all tables, because we want to honour the work we do with them.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Terry Duguid

“I support this bill. It gives First Nations control over their own water systems, sets clear water standards, and provides the money to back it up.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the authority, clear standards, historic funding and sustained support are at the core of the bill. I am proud to have ensured that this government, the only government, has pushed forth the bill to support real jurisdiction over water systems, to create standards, and to govern these systems according to their rights, priorities and lived reality.

In response to a question from Terry Duguid

“This bill gives First Nations the legal power and tools to manage their own drinking water and wastewater. It lets them set their own clean water rules.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, that was an important question. Bill C-37 would ensure that first nations have the authority and means to deliver safe, reliable drinking water in their communities. By affirming jurisdiction over water sources and by also ensuring drinking water and waste water for first nations, we would be enabling the development of clear, consistent, first nations-led standards. The authority— An hon. member: Oh, oh!

In response to a question from Billy Morin

“Our government is spending $5.9 billion on reserve housing. We are helping First Nations train workers and plan and manage their own housing. The opposition barely built any homes when they were in power.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 34 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am really proud to be here and do the work, and I invite my colleague to work with us in advancing the things we are determining: $5.9 billion to support on-reserve housing, ensuring that over 55% of first nations have housing plans, ensuring that communities have housing managers and ensuring that they are accessing the training and certification to build those homes, because we are not only building homes, but we are equipping first nations with the resources they need to do the job. Only this government has done that. We can look at the track record of the opposition. I think it is 99 homes, maybe fewer.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Leah Gazan

“Past laws wrongly took away official status from thousands of First Nations people, and the harm remains today. A committee is studying this bill now. We need to let First Nations witnesses speak for themselves, and I want to work with the member to respect their rights.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the process of enfranchisement unjustly stripped thousands of first nations individuals of their status. While the practice was ended 35 years ago, the harmful legacy still remains. That member knows that this bill is before study at the committee. That member knows that there are witnesses, and we want to respect those first nations witnesses’ rights to come to defend and speak for themselves and their communities. I am willing to work with that member to respect those first nations rights, because this is what we are committed to doing.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Lori Idlout

“It is National Indigenous History Month, and my home community of Waswanipi is celebrating its 50th anniversary today. I am honouring all First Nations, Inuit, and Métis people, our strength, and our culture.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 47 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Signal 38 of 100

    Much of this statement went to praise, blame, greetings, routine procedure or general stories rather than reasons, requests or specific points.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my hon. colleague for that important question. As an Eeyou iskwew from the community of Waswanipi, which is celebrating its 50th anniversary today, I know we are taking moments this month to honour who we are as part of National Indigenous History Month. We are here to celebrate our strength, resilience and culture. I am proud to work with my colleagues who are first nations, Inuit and Métis, demonstrating the fierce resistance representing every part of this country. [Member spoke in Cree and provided the following translation:] I want to acknowledge all first nations, Inuit and Métis people and I honour them.

Oral Questions ·

Indigenous Affairs

In response to a question from Jenny Kwan

“A committee is studying this bill right now. I welcome feedback, and we are working with groups across the country. We want to remove the barriers in the Indian Act that take away First Nations status.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Clarity 36 of 100

    Much of this statement used imprecise wording, lacked details on timing or responsibility, or made broad claims without support.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I think the member is well aware that Bill S-2 is in front of the committee for study. I welcome her input. We are there to ensure that enfranchisement, the intention of the bill, is responded to. We continue to work closely with groups across the country, hearing their input. I am open to supporting these communities, because enfranchisement quantifies who indigenous people are under the Indian Act. We are trying to ensure that we remove the barriers of the Indian Act for first nations people in this country. I am working on that.

In response to a question from Marilène Gill

“Past governments did not give Indigenous people enough money. Our government is spending more money to support Indigenous nations and people in both cities and rural areas across Canada.”
  • Government answer in Question Period

    Relevance 45 of 100

    None of this answer addressed the specific question that was asked.

    See full analysis
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, for decades, there was underfunding and discrimination in this file. I am proud to work with the only government that has decided to take a stand and add funding to this file to meet the needs of indigenous nations in Quebec and across Canada. I am proud to be doing this work. I am very pleased to note that, under urban and rural programs, in big cities and in the north, we are doing this work together, not only with the nations, but also with people in urban centres. That is very important.

In response to a question from Gabriel Ste-Marie

“Housing is a top priority in Indigenous communities. We are launching a plan to work with these communities and build the homes they need.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am glad to hear a question on such an important issue, which is a first. We know that housing is a top priority in indigenous communities. That is why I am proud to be working with my colleagues to launch the program to build Canada strong and build homes in indigenous communities. We will build these homes together with them, to meet their needs. I am proud to be doing this work with them, and we will stay the course.