Stand on Guard Act

Bill C-270, Stand on Guard Act · Second reading · now at second reading in the House Where it stands

What Bill C-270 would do

The bill would amend the Criminal Code to add legal presumptions related to the defence of a person. The published material gives no further detail.

Official text (opens in a new tab)

12 statements

Sandra Cobena, Newmarket—Aurora

Conservative
“I want the House to pass my bill and send it to committee. It changes the law so that if someone breaks into your home, the court assumes they meant to hurt you and assumes the force you used to defend your family was reasonable unless evidence shows otherwise.”
Official Hansard

moved that Bill C-270, An Act to amend the Criminal Code (defence of person), be read the second time and referred to a committee. She said: Mr. Speaker, since I was elected to the House, I have had the privilege of speaking with so many Canadians. They speak about the cost of living, about their children and about the future of this country, but they consistently speak about something more fundamental. They speak about the fear that the place they have always considered their safe place may no longer be as secure. That place is their home. There are certain things in life that should not require explanation. A family should be able to sleep peacefully at night. A person should be able to close the door of their home and know that within those walls, they have a right to protect the people they love. However, across our country, Canadians have seen enough cases where a homeowner is dragged through the justice system only to prove that they had been protecting their family from a criminal breaking into their home. Canadians are reasonably asking whether our laws adequately protect them in the place where they should feel the safest. That is why I introduced my private member’s bill, the stand on guard act. It would give special legal recognition to something Canadians have always understood: Our home is our safe place. It is, after all, what we teach our children, that there is nowhere else in the world where they are safer than at home in the arms of mom and dad. This same home deserves special protection under our laws. The legislation before us would strengthen protection for law-abiding Canadians who are forced to defend themselves or their family during a home invasion. Consider a mother asleep in her home. It is 2 a.m., and her children are sleeping down the hall. Suddenly she hears glass breaking. She hears footsteps. Someone is inside her home. She does not know who he is. She does not know if he is armed. She does not know what he intends to do. She knows only one thing: Her children are in danger. She has seconds, not minutes and not hours, to decide what to do. In those seconds, she must act. Now consider what happens afterwards. It is bed time again. What does she say to a child who wants to know why locking the door will keep them safe tonight when it did not last night? The legal process rolls. Statements are taken, and the police reports are submitted. In York region, 43 home invasions took place in 2025 alone. Under our current laws, whether the force the mother used was reasonable may be judged against a long list of circumstances: the size and physical ability of the people involved, the presence of weapons, the nature of the threat and the alternatives that may have been available. These considerations have their place in the law, but there is something profoundly unreasonable about asking a frightened mother, awakened in the darkness, to make judgements that lawyers and judges may spend hours examining in the calm of the light of day. The criminal had the luxury of choosing his actions. The mother had no choice but to defend her children. That difference matters, and our laws should recognize it. We want to change the law so Canadians can act with certainty when their loved ones are put in danger. Our amendment to the Criminal Code would protect the innocent in three ways. First, if a violent intruder breaks into somebody’s home and threatens their family, the law would finally be on their side, not on the intruder’s side. Second, it would presume reasonableness. The force used to stop a home invader who poses a threat would be deemed reasonable. There would be no more second-guessing after the fact. Third, it would end legal limbo. Canadians defending themselves should not spend years in court, while criminals walk free. This proposed law would give clarity to citizens, police and prosecutors. The stand on guard act recognizes the difference and would establish two important legal presumptions. First, when someone knowingly and unlawfully enters an occupied home, the law should presume that the intruder intends to use force against the people inside unless the evidence establishes otherwise. Second, when a person uses force to defend themselves or their loved one in those circumstances, the force would be presumed reasonable unless the evidence establishes otherwise. This would extend to lethal force as it may be needed in self-defence. It is important to understand what this means. It is not a licence for violence. It is not an unlimited right to use force. The presumption can be rebutted. Evidence still matters. Courts retain the responsibility to examine the facts, but the law would begin by recognizing a fundamental difference: One person chose to violate the security of another’s home. The other was forced to respond. The law should stand with those forced to defend themselves or a loved one in those circumstances. That force should be presumed reasonable unless the evidence shows otherwise. This is about restoring common sense to our justice system. A person’s home is their safe place and deserves special legal protection under Canadian law. The bill would send an unequivocal message to police, prosecutors and judges that our homes benefit from unique legal standing. A home invasion terrorizes not only the victims but also the entire community, who also feel less safe. Equally, it would send a message to criminals that the law stands with the person who is forced to defend themselves and their family. Canadians want the natural truth set out clearly in our Criminal Code. If someone knowingly and unlawfully enters my home, the force used to protect me or my family is presumed to be reasonable, full stop. This bill is simply in recognition of the truth we already know. A person’s home is not a sidewalk. It is not a bar. It is not a workplace. A home is something altogether different. It is where people build a life, where children take their first steps, where families gather around the dinner table, where parents sit at the edge of a child’s bed and whisper good night. It is where we are the most vulnerable. We trust that the walls around us mean something and that the door we close at night marks a boundary the law will respect. When someone knowingly and unlawfully crosses that boundary, the law should recognize the gravity of what has happened. That is the principle at the heart of the bill. A person’s home is their safe place, and it deserves special protection under Canadian law. Right now, a person’s home does not have special legal protection under our laws. The stand on guard act would change that and enshrine it in the Criminal Code. Yes, we know this deep inside. A home is special. It is our human right to defend it. It is our place. Until recently, Canadians never had to even think about home invasions, but after a decade of bad Liberal policies, now we do. We need to enshrine rights that are so deeply human that they are written in our conscience and our laws. We need our Criminal Code to actually say clearly what we all know is true. When I introduced this bill on March 12, I was overwhelmed by the attention it received. Five days later, there was a home invasion in Vaughan. What was the headline? “No charges against Ontario resident who shot and injured alleged home invader: police”. It was almost like a sigh of relief that this time, the homeowner was not charged. It was also a reflection that Canadians are particularly interested and concerned with self-defence in the context of a home invasion. That article went on to state that, “Ari Goldkind, a criminal defence lawyer, said he finds it ‘refreshing’ that the police did not charge the homeowner.” The article also recounts, “Last month, prosecutors withdrew charges against a man in Lindsay, Ont., who had been accused of assaulting an alleged home intruder in August 2025.” In this case, the home intruder came into his home with a crossbow, and the victim needed to defend himself with a knife. Canadians have had enough of laws that leave them uncertain of their rights when they are most vulnerable. They want to know that when a criminal violates the safety of their home, the law recognizes the difference between the person who created the danger and the family forced to confront it. That is why I am bringing forward the stand on guard act. It is to give a family defending their home a clear legal presumption of reasonableness, while preserving the ability of courts to consider evidence to the contrary. Someone’s home is their safe place and it deserves special legal protection under our laws. This legislation would not create a blanket immunity and would not import U.S.-style “stand your ground” laws. It would be a targeted Canadian clarification anchored in the existing section 34 reasonableness standard. The stand on guard principle would affirm the home is a unique protected space; make it clear in the law that when a violent intruder breaks into someone’s home and threatens their family, the law is on their side, not the intruder’s side; if someone uses force to stop a home invader who poses a threat, that force will be presumed reasonable; it would be an unequivocal message to police, prosecutors and judges that a home benefits from a unique legal standing; it would signal legal certainty that protects families and discourages offenders; it would preserve safeguards or proportionality and individualized assessment; and it would improve transparency and public understanding of self-defence in the home, reinforcing confidence in the administration of justice. Canadians are calling for stronger self-defence laws in a home. Conservatives have heard that and know that our self-defence laws need to treat a home differently and uniquely. The stand on guard act is not about right or left. It is about whether we hear the call from Canadians to strengthen self-defence laws in the unique context of a home invasion. The question confronting us is simple: Do we believe that a home is a safe place that deserves special legal protection under our laws, yes or no? I hope the answer from every member of this House is yes. A vote for yes means this bill goes to committee to be studied and refined. A vote no means the government does not even hear the call of Canadians to strengthen self-defence laws. Someone’s home should be their safe place, not the place where the law turns against them for protecting the people they love.

Marilyn Gladu, Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong

Liberal
“I want to know if current laws already protect people who shoot home invaders. I also want to know if police support this bill.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank the member opposite for bringing this bill forward. I am interested to know a couple of things. She talked about the incident where someone shot somebody who was trying to invade their home and they did not get arrested. Does the existing legal framework protect us in that way? What kind of stakeholder engagement has there been? What do the police think? What have you heard?

Sandra Cobena, Newmarket—Aurora

Conservative
“This bill changes our self-defence laws. It assumes that if you defend yourself or your family inside your own home, you used reasonable force. The public and the police support this change.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, there is a difference between the current self-defence laws and what the bill is proposing. The difference is that there is a clear presumption up front. If someone defends themselves or their family inside of their own home, it is presumed that the force they use is reasonable. In terms of stakeholders and feedback from the broader community and police officers, it has been nothing but positive. In my speech, I mentioned how popular this was. I think it is because it is such a priority for the community.

Alexis Deschênes, Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj

Bloc Québécois
“Our laws already allow people to defend themselves and their homes. An Ontario person recently shot an intruder and was found not guilty. Laws like this one in Florida led to more gun deaths. Has the member looked into the real impact of this bill?”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her contribution to the debate. In her speech, she mentioned the case in Ontario. An individual is the victim of a home invasion, grabs a gun, shoots the intruder, and seriously injures them. That person pleads self-defence and is acquitted. This example demonstrates that the Criminal Code currently provides people with the necessary certainty and security to defend their property. Has my colleague looked into the impact of what she is proposing? This type of law was implemented in Florida, and it was found to have increased the rate of gun-related homicides, because the argument is that as soon as someone enters without permission, the homeowner can shoot them in the head and be cleared of any wrongdoing.

Sandra Cobena, Newmarket—Aurora

Conservative
“I want this bill to pass. People who defend themselves often face jail time, lose their jobs, and spend thousands of dollars on lawyers before their charges are dropped. This law will protect innocent Canadians from going through the justice system just for defending themselves and their families.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the case in the example the member cited ignores one fact. When a person is charged, even if the charges are eventually dropped, they are dragged through the justice system. There are cases where someone had been in jail for six months but the charges were not dropped until two years later. They lost their job, and, of course, they had to spend thousands of dollars in legal fees only to prove that they had been defending themselves. That is what this law would prevent. It would prevent lawful Canadians from having to be dragged through the justice system only to prove that they had been defending themselves and their family.

Michael Guglielmin, Vaughan—Woodbridge

Conservative

Linked statement

“Home break-ins are up in my area, and people do not feel safe in their homes. If someone defends themselves against an intruder, they should not face long and expensive legal trouble. I want to pass this bill to make the law clear for homeowners.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, my colleague comes from the area in York region in which I reside. There has been an increase in home invasions in this region. More importantly, we are starting to see a trend in which citizens who live there do not feel safe in their own home. There have been countless examples in victim impact statements after home invasions of the trauma that is inflicted on the family. There is a calling by many of citizens for the need to feel they can defend themselves without facing undue process or being dragged through very complicated and expensive legal proceedings simply for having defended themselves. Could the member speak about the need for this clarity in the law, and what that would signal to individuals in their own home if they happen to face a circumstance where some intruders enter their home with weapons that may be concealed, as they are in a lot of cases?

Sandra Cobena, Newmarket—Aurora

Conservative
“I support this bill. Home invasions scare entire communities, not just the families who are attacked. Homes are different from public places, and families need clear legal protection to defend themselves against intruders.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, the member is entirely right. When a home invasion happens, there is a ripple effect in terms of the impact. It is not just the family whose home is invaded. It is also the broader community that is frightened. There have been a number of cases within the GTA, the riding the member represents. This bill would confirm that a home deserves special protections under the law. A home is not the same as a bar. It is not the same as a public park or even a commercial property. The home is different. It is where families are most vulnerable, and they deserve the clarity that they can defend themselves when an intruder comes in.

Kevin Lamoureux, Parliamentary Secretary to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons

Liberal
“We do not need this bill. Canadians already have the right to defend themselves in their homes. Our courts and police already have the power to handle these cases. We have already passed good laws to keep people safe, like our changes to bail.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it is very important, in debating this issue, that we look at the issue in its simplest form. Our laws today already guarantee and provide the right to defend oneself when there is someone in one’s home. It already exists today. An hon. member: Not true. Hon. Kevin Lamoureux: Yes, it is true. Mr. Speaker, if we look at the types of legislation the government has brought in to date, we see there are all kinds of ways the government has proactively dealt with making our communities safe. I want to go through a number of those initiatives, so that we can clearly demonstrate that we understand what the concerns of Canadians are, as a whole, when it comes to the issue of safety. That is why I want to start off by making it perfectly clear that Canadians have the right to self-defence in their homes. I will go through some of the criteria that enable them to have that level of confidence. In the interim, I want to pick up on the other point, in terms of legislation we have dealt with. We have even passed private members’ bills, and even opposition private members’ bills, on the issue of crime and our communities and how we can make them safer. This is not a bill in which the member has clearly demonstrated whether there are any provinces that are onside. We need to recognize that it is a joint responsibility. In our judicial system, it is the police who actually look for the charges to be laid, supported by the Crown. It is our courts and our judges who have the discretionary authority to ultimately make the determination. We already have the criminal law today that provides that right, so I do not see why the legislation is actually warranted. We can look at how seriously the government has taken the issue of crime and making our communities safer. All we need to do is look at the legislative agenda. I would challenge the member who is proposing the bill to tell me of another prime minister in generations who has brought forward such a legislative agenda to improve and make our communities safer. I could talk about Bill C-16, for example. It recognizes, for the first time, the issue of femicide. It deals with coercive behaviour in relationships. For me, personally, I like that it reinstates many mandatory minimums. That is Bill C-16 in a nutshell. I believe that at the end of the day, we will see a direct benefit from Bill C-16. Again, with Bill C-270, which we have before us, I will continue to reflect on the fact that it is just not required. It makes a powerful statement, yes, but is it actually required? I would say no. We could talk about my favourite piece of legislation, which we had to fight extensively to get through the House. That was the bail reform legislation. As an example, the member asked me to tell him what provinces are onside. They asked if the chiefs of police and law enforcement in general are onside, and if stakeholders are onside. We can contrast that to Bill C-14, the bail reform legislation, which was widely supported. Provinces and municipalities, including my home province of Manitoba, were calling for that legislation, and we brought it forward. The legislation was of a substantial nature, and interestingly enough, yesterday, on November 18, there was a report on CBC. The headline included a quote from a Newfoundland and Labrador judge who denied bail to a man who bragged about Canada’s easy release. The quote was, “Not anymore”, and it continued, “Justice Vikas Khaladkar cites new law in denying bail for repeat offender”. As a member of the government, I can assure the member opposite that every member of the Liberal caucus wants to make our communities safer. That is why the government was very frustrated with the official opposition standing in the way of passing Bill C-14. It took a great deal of effort from the government to get it through. That was the comment made by the judge just yesterday, talking about how that bill has made a difference. This was legislation for a change that was widely supported, not only by our constituents but also by the many different stakeholders. There was no misleading information going into it. We had the confidence of our judicial system, whether it was judges, law enforcement or Crowns, but we recognized there was a need to change. All of the different groups made the case for it. The government recognized it, and we have brought forward a number of pieces of legislation to the legislature, or the House, for passage. There were others. One bill is still in the Senate, Bill C-22, on lawful access. I do not know how many times I have heard, not only on this bill but also on other pieces of legislation, the minister responsible for crime talking about how important this legislation was to all of Canada in making our communities safer and that we need to see it pass. It is still in the Senate. We would like to see it pass in a timely fashion, and hopefully, it will. Bill C-9 and Bill C-12 are to make our communities safer. As I pointed out at the beginning of my speech, we have had private member’s bills, some from the opposition benches, all dealing with crime. We supported them and got them through or pushed to get them through. If we look at the current law in place, it is very easy to make the statement that Canadians already have the right to defend themselves in their homes. We believe and have confidence in our judiciary system administering that law appropriately. We are not going to interfere and challenge them to the degree Conservatives do based on raising money for their party. That seems to be the motivating factor far too often when it comes to crime.

Alexis Deschênes, Gaspésie—Les Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Listuguj

Bloc Québécois
“I am voting against this bill. The law already lets people protect themselves and their homes if they act reasonably. This bill assumes that anyone who enters a home uninvited plans to use force. That could let people legally kill a harmless intruder by mistake. Similar laws in the United States led to more gun deaths. We do not need this change.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am going to tell two fictional stories. They will help everyone better understand what is being proposed in Bill C-270. Here is the first scenario. I am at home, and someone opens the door and enters uninvited. He is armed and approaches me. He appears threatening and, to protect myself, I punch him. He falls and dies. I could be charged, but I think I have a good chance of being acquitted under the current concept of self-defence in the Criminal Code. The conditions set out in section 34 of the Criminal Code must be met. First, I believed on reasonable grounds that a threat of force was being made against me. Second, I acted to defend or protect myself, not to get revenge. Third, I acted reasonably in the circumstances, that is, I threw a punch to overcome the threat. I think I would be acquitted. Now for the second scenario. I am incredibly fortunate to have three extraordinary, wonderful boys. They are great kids and have lots of friends. In my village of Carleton-sur-Mer, my house is always full because my sons are constantly inviting their friends over to eat, study or spend the night. When there is a party somewhere in the village, it always ends up at our house. There is a steady stream of people coming and going. Let us say that one of my sons’ friends forgets his shoes and decides to come back and get them at 9:30 p.m. Since he is used to stopping in, he opens the door without knocking and comes in to get his shoes. It just so happens that I have a gun and I shoot him, because this young man entered my home knowingly and without having the legal right to do so. If Bill C-270 is passed, I think I would be acquitted. What Bill C-270 states is that, when someone knowingly enters a house without being entitled by law to do so, it can be presumed that the person entered with intent to use force against me. The presumption referred to in Bill C-270 is what will allow me to use lethal force against anyone who, without having the legal right to do so, has entered a residential property in which I am lawfully present. Is that what we want? Of course not. Basically, Bill C-270 gives people permission to kill anyone who enters their home uninvited. It is a bit like the wild west. As I said in the beginning, people have the right to defend themselves under the self-defence provisions of the Criminal Code. However, I think that it is worrisome to go so far as to presume that there is an intent to use force and justifying the use of lethal force without taking into account the context. That is not going to solve any real problems and will mainly lead to tragic mistakes or deaths, which is not what we want. The purpose of criminal law is to keep people safe. Telling people that they can use lethal force against anyone who enters their home uninvited will not make our society safer. It will do the opposite. Other countries, including the United States, have tried this approach. If we do a little research, we find that the only state where this is still legal is Texas. Florida tried implementing this type of legislation and found that it led to a significant increase in the rate of firearm-related homicides. In 57% of cases, there was clear evidence that the person claiming self-defence could have retreated to safety without attacking. What is dangerous about this bill is that it opens the door to homicides. If we look at the law as it currently stands, a contextual analysis is already carried out. That is why I do not think this bill solves anything. Currently, there is the defence of the person, but there is also the defence of property. This defence is also allowed in the Criminal Code. If we think that someone is going to damage our property, we can also use force to stop the threat. However, the Criminal Code provides certain safeguards. My colleague spoke about the uncertainty surrounding all this, but I would not call it uncertainty. On the contrary, the objective is simply to ensure that people are not permitted to go too far and seek revenge by using disproportionate force. The purpose of self-defence or the defence of property is to stop the threat, to stop the use of force. The Criminal Code provides for a way to determine self-defence. As I said, there are three criteria: the person must believe that force will be used against them or that there is a threat; the person must act for the purpose of defending or protecting themselves; and the act committed is reasonable. For a determination of whether a person acted reasonably, the Criminal Code already sets out a number of factors that can be used to contextualize the behaviour. For example, the person’s gender can be taken into consideration. Certain subjective criteria can be used for contextualization purposes. If a person experiences fear when someone else might not, the nature of the force or threat would be examined, along with the extent to which the use of force was imminent. The judge would also consider the history of any relationship between the parties to the incident to determine whether the use of force was reasonable. For example, if the person reacted very quickly but there was a history of violence or intimidation, the reaction could be considered reasonable in the circumstances. The judge will also examine any history of interaction, as well as the nature and proportionality of the person’s response, along with whether the person was acting in response to a use or threat of force that they knew was lawful. If so, that complicates the matter. Nothing is perfect, but the Criminal Code does currently allow someone who is the victim of a home invasion, which is the type of case our colleague mentioned, to defend themselves if they have a reasonable fear, and to put a stop to that threat. What more could we want? I think that the status quo is fine, but when we look at Bill C-270, there really is a presumption of intent that changes the legal analysis and sends a message that, in my view, should not exist. That is why the Bloc Québécois is voting against this bill.

Pierre Poilievre, Leader of the Opposition

Conservative
“I want the House to pass this bill. Violent crime has gone up under the Liberals because their laws let repeat offenders out on bail and reduce prison time. Right now, our self-defence laws are too vague, and innocent people risk going to jail just for protecting themselves. This bill ensures that if someone breaks into your house, the law assumes you acted legally to defend your family, even if you used deadly force. We also need tougher sentences for home invaders and stricter bail rules to keep dangerous criminals off our streets.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, it was a night like any other for the Morton family, sound asleep in their beds, assuming they were safe. Then, shortly after 4 a.m., the door smashed open. Masked and armed criminals jolted them awake by forcing themselves in with a hammer. They shot the father, David Morton, and his two daughters. They attacked everyone in the house with hammers. In mere minutes, the place where the family should have felt most at home, quite literally, and most safe turned into a crime scene. No family should have to wake up to this kind of horrifying nightmare, but this is the reality after 11 years of Liberal laws and the resulting chaos. Since 2015, violent crime is up in Canada by 57%, sexual assault by 77%, human trafficking by 119%, and extortion, which, by the way, is a home invasion-related offence, by 297%. Canadians deserve to be safe in their homes and on the streets. Instead, they worry about the sound of breaking glass in the middle of the night. How did we get here? Law after law after law that Liberals have passed siding with criminals and turning them loose on our streets have awakened a monster. Bill C-75, regarding Liberal bail, which requires judges to release repeat offenders at the earliest opportunity under the least onerous conditions, which is quoted right out of the act, often allows the same offender to be released hundreds of times and rearrested in between those releases, punctuating our society with endless crime. Bill C-5 removed mandatory jail time for serious offences and allowed serious criminals to serve their sentences in their living room. The present Prime Minister put forward Bill C-16, allowing judges to ignore almost all mandatory prison sentences in the Criminal Code, including those for extortion, firearms, human trafficking and aggravated sexual assault with a gun. Even the Liberals’ so-called bail reform, Bill C-14, continues to allow repeat offenders to be released onto our streets again and again. The law is not on our side. Let us be clear. The law is not defending the Canadian people, and it does not let them defend themselves. The current laws related to self-defence and home defence are too vague, leave too much discretion and risk dragging law-abiding people through a devastating and expensive legal process and potentially sending them to jail for the mere offence of protecting themselves and their property. Courts will decide if self-defence was justified, whether the person acted on “reasonable grounds”, but, of course, no one has time to think about the legal definition of reasonable grounds when someone has smashed through a window and crawled with a weapon into their children’s bedroom. Their priority in that circumstance is to protect themselves and their family. However, when we raised the issue, the Liberal justice minister said we were trying to create what he called the Wild West. He should tell that to the family in Vaughan who watched as their father and husband was taken from them. In August of last year, three armed robbers forced their way into the family’s home, the place where they celebrate birthdays and where they sit around the dinner table, where they are supposed to feel safe. One intruder held the daughter at gunpoint. The father did what any parent would do. He stepped in between the gunman and his daughter, and for that, he was shot and killed. His daughter watched as he was murdered. They saw him lose his life. The primary suspect was there because he was out on bail. Of course he was out on bail. Who is not out on bail that is committing crimes? In fact, he had been released on bail not once, but four times. After 11 years, Minister, this is the Wild West. The Wild West is everywhere in our streets. Just this month, at a grocery store in Prince George, British Columbia, three criminals tried to leave the store with $2,000 of unpaid groceries. An ordinary workday quickly turned violent. When employees stood up to them, they were attacked. One employee and a 20-year-old manager were attacked. That young manager showed up to work to do his job and earn a paycheque. Instead, he went to the hospital with multiple injuries. One of the men charged was a repeat offender, again released under the Liberal catch-and-release system. That is why Conservatives have put forward concrete solutions to keep people safe in their homes and on the streets. I am so proud of the hon. member for Newmarket—Aurora for putting forward this castle law so that people can stand their ground and keep their families safe. Her proposed bill would change subsection 34(2) of the Criminal Code regarding the use of force, including lethal force. If it is used against someone who has illegally and knowingly entered one’s home, it is presumed that someone is acting lawfully in applying a counterforce, including a lethal counterforce. Simply put, if someone knowingly and unlawfully enters someone’s home, they should be allowed to use any force that they deem necessary to protect their family. Liberals and others in the House might say, “Does that not put someone’s life in danger, if the homeowner potentially overreacts?” I have a solution for that. If someone does not want to be harmed by someone in their house, they should not break in. It is that simple. We want to ensure that, if somebody stands up in the middle of the night and makes the split-second judgment that is potentially necessary to protect their home against someone who has invaded it, they will not face the grind of our legal system and potentially jail time. I should also point out that this bill would add to the stand-alone Criminal Code offence that the safe at home act would add to. That is another Conservative bill that would make more penalties apply to people who invade homes. We have a double approach to protecting homes. One approach is to give people the power to defend themselves. The second is to make sure that anyone who invades faces a minimum sentence of five years and a maximum sentence of life in prison with a reverse onus bail provision. We call on Liberals and all members of Parliament to support these bills in addition to the jail not bail act, which the Liberals voted against. We asked them to revive that bill. It would crack down on repeat violent offenders and strengthen bail laws. It would repeal Liberal bail. This is the so-called “principle of restraint” that requires judges to release accused “at the earliest opportunity under the least onerous conditions”. We should repeal that and allow judges to put public safety first when assessing whether the accused is a danger to society. We also ask the government to revive the bill it defeated, the one law for all bill. It would ensure that judges could no longer give a discount sentence to someone on the basis that they are visiting Canada and applying for immigration. Right now, judges are lowering sentences for visiting foreign nationals who are not permanent residents or citizens so that they will not jeopardize their immigration application or, in other words, to keep them in Canada. If a foreign national visiting our country commits a serious crime, they should do the full sentence and be immediately deported from our country. Foreign nationals who commit crimes should not get lollipop sentences just because they are not Canadian citizens or permanent residents. While Conservatives continue to put law-abiding Canadians first, the Liberals are putting criminals first, and enough is enough. Canadians deserve an end to the revolving door. They deserve to know that criminals will go behind bars. The law-abiding, decent, honourable people who work hard, pay their taxes and play by the rules should expect to live in safety and tranquility. If, God forbid that moment ever comes, someone invades their most sacred place for their family, they should also know that they can defend themselves using any force necessary. We would empower Canadians to defend themselves, their families and their homes, using any force they deem necessary to stop criminals, because it is time for the government and the country to stand on the side of law-abiding, innocent Canadians, especially in their homes.

Doug Eyolfson, Winnipeg West

Liberal
“I oppose this bill. Our self-defence laws already protect people who use reasonable force to defend themselves. Changing the law could justify violence against people who wander into the wrong home by mistake or who pose no threat.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, I am pleased today to rise to speak to this private member’s bill, Bill C-270, an act to amend the Criminal Code in relation to defence of person. Bill C-270 was introduced by the member for Newmarket—Aurora, and it proposes to reform Canada’s self-defence law. The intended objective of the bill, as I understand it, is to prevent victims of home invasions who act in defence of themselves, their family and their property from being criminally charged. While I believe this is a well-intentioned attempt to strengthen protection for victims of home invasions, which are terrifying crimes that can have long-lasting and profound effects on victims, I cannot support the bill. Criminal law is made up of offences and defences. Offences are prohibited acts, done with the required mental state, that carry criminal consequences, including jail time. These include, among many others, assault, manslaughter and murder. Defences, on the other hand, are legal justifications that can block criminal liability for the commission of an offence. This includes self-defence. Our existing self-defence law shields people who use reasonable defensive force, including lethal force, from criminal liability. More specifically, it permits people to use force if they had a reasonable belief in a threat of harm, they responded defensively and their response was reasonable considering all the circumstances. In assessing whether the use of force was reasonable, the courts will consider a wide range of factors, including the nature and imminence of the threat, whether weapons were involved, the relative physical capabilities of the people involved, and any prior relationship or communication between the parties. Importantly, the current law favours accused persons in self-defence cases. This is because the prosecutor must not only prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a criminal offence was committed but must also disprove self-defence beyond a reasonable doubt. Put differently, in order to secure a conviction, the prosecutor must prove not only that the person committed an offence but also that they did not do so in self-defence. The burden on the prosecution to secure a conviction is, rightly, very high. Canada’s self-defence law is, in my view, operating effectively and as intended. I am not aware of any case where someone has been convicted of an offence when acting in self-defence. The issue of charging practices is an important but separate issue from the Criminal Code laws that apply to self-defence. Take, for example, the 2025 home invasion in Lindsay, Ontario, that resulted in a violent altercation between the tenant, Jeremy McDonald, and the intruder, Michael Kyle Breen. Mr. McDonald used a knife to defend himself and left Mr. Breen with serious, life-threatening injuries. While Mr. McDonald was initially charged with aggravated assault and assault with a weapon, the prosecutors ultimately withdrew the charges against him after reviewing all the evidence. The charges against Mr. Breen, including for breaking and entering, were not dropped, and in April 2026 he pleaded guilty. There was also the 2019 home invasion in Collingwood, Ontario, in which the homeowner, Cameron Gardiner, killed Dean Copkov and Donovan Bass, two masked and armed intruders who broke into his house. This was the result of a struggle between Mr. Gardiner and one of the intruders over a shotgun. While Mr. Gardiner was originally charged with two counts of manslaughter, the charges against him were eventually withdrawn. In Canada, police lay charges when they have reasonable and probable grounds to believe that a criminal offence has been committed. Defences, such as self-defence, are legal justifications that must be disproved by prosecutors in court. Thorough prosecutorial screening prior to charges being laid reduces the likelihood of charges being improperly laid in self-defence cases, rather than having them withdrawn after the fact and after the damage is done. Being charged with an offence, especially a serious offence such as aggravated assault or manslaughter, can have devastating impacts on a person. In the context of violent home invasions, this can also be retraumatizing for the victims. Some provinces and territories already require prosecutors to evaluate police evidence to, among other things, determine before criminal charges are laid whether there is a substantial likelihood of conviction. These practices are in constant evolution by law enforcement at the provincial and territorial level. Bill C-270 proposes to change the existing self-defence law by creating a presumption that the mere fact that a person unlawfully entered house is proof that they intended to use force against someone in that house, and that force used against that person was used in self-defence. This would make it more difficult to hold those who do not act in self-defence criminally liable for violence committed against a person who unlawfully enters their home. This would capture a broad set of circumstances that would not be limited to violent home invasions, like the ones I just discussed. Take, for example, a situation where a senior accidentally enters the wrong apartment after getting off the elevator on the wrong floor and is assaulted by the resident, or, in the intimate partner violence context, a situation where a woman goes to her boyfriend’s house, an argument breaks out, and he assaults or, worse, kills her but claims that she was there unlawfully since he did not invite her over and she does not live there. These are two examples of situations where the “intruder” did not pose any threat of harm, yet under Bill C-270, the proposed self-defence law, the violence committed against them would be presumed to be legally justified. Surely this is not the sponsor’s intent. I would like to remind hon. members that the existing self-defence law came to be in 2013, following Parliament’s enactment of Bill C-26, an act to amend the Criminal Code, citizen’s arrest and the defences of property and persons. This bill was introduced by the Conservative government at the time. As I stated at the outset of my remarks, a person will, under the current law, be shielded from criminal liability if they acted in self-defence, meaning that they had a reasonable belief in a threat of harm, they responded defensively and their response was reasonable considering all of the circumstances. I strongly believe that the existing self-defence law strikes the right balance between recognizing that people need to defend themselves in dangerous situations, while ensuring that appropriate limits are placed on the use of force, and particularly on the use of lethal force. Our self-defence law does not, and should not, permit violence to be committed against someone merely because they trespass. This is why I oppose this bill.

Tamara Kronis, Nanaimo—Ladysmith

Conservative
“I want the House to pass this bill. Right now, people who protect their families during a home invasion can spend years and thousands of dollars defending themselves in court. This bill changes the law to assume an intruder intends to use force and that a homeowner acted in self-defence.”
Official Hansard

Mr. Speaker, a home invasion is a truly terrifying thing. Someone has broken into the place where a family is supposed to be safe. A parent may have seconds to decide what to do. They grab whatever blunt object is handy and protect their family as best they can. Afterwards, because of the way our criminal law works, that parent may spend months or years, and thousands of dollars, answering for that decision in court. Bill C-270 is about presumptions. Under the current law, the court looks at whether someone reasonably believed force was being used or threatened, whether they acted to protect themself or someone else, and whether their response was reasonable in the circumstances. Once there is evidence to support self-defence, the Crown has to disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt, but that does not prevent an investigation, a charge or a costly legal fight. This bill would change that. It would change subsection 34(2) of the Criminal Code to create two presumptions for unlawful entry into a home. If someone knowingly and unlawfully enters, the law would presume they intended to use force unless there is evidence to the contrary. That is kind of a match for hearing breaking glass in the middle of the night in one’s home and hearing someone moving around. If a resident uses force against someone who has unlawfully entered, the conditions for self-defence would be presumed to be met. That changes the starting point for a court reviewing a frightening, split-second event, and it changes what officers are able to do when they arrive on the scene. It changes the way the whole situation is approached. The reason that is important is that the legal cost of defending oneself in a self-defence situation can be substantial. One man reported that it cost about $60,000 in legal costs over a two-and-a-half-year fight after men had firebombed his Ontario home and he fired warning shots. He was eventually acquitted of firearms-related charges, and much of his legal bill was covered by supporters. That is one case that shows how costly a legal fight arising from a home attack can become. I lived through this myself with a friend when I was practising law. It is a terrible experience. In that case, it was someone in my local community. It was 18 months before he even got his cellphone back because the RCMP were investigating whether or not charges would be laid against him. A person who has just lived through a crime should not have to face years of uncertainty over whether a court will consider that their split-second response was reasonable. What Bill C-270 would do is give clearer recognition in the law and set the presumption where we naturally think it should be. When someone breaks into our home, when someone invades our space, when we are scared, it is natural to do whatever it takes to defend ourselves. It is natural to reach for whatever is at hand. It is natural to act in any way that is open to us, especially if it is a place where we have family who are sleeping. What this bill would do, and Canadians are behind this, is help bring the law toward the place where a reasonable person would believe it should be. It would make life more secure for people who face uncertainty. It would make it easier for police and our society to act. I see that I am reaching the end of my time, so I will leave it there. I am thankful for the opportunity to speak to this bill today.

Discussion

No comments yet

See the full discussion

Comment rules

More from sitting 168

  1. Government Orders The Budget 116 statements
  2. Oral Questions Housing 5 statements
  3. Oral Questions Finance 6 statements
  4. Oral Questions The Environment 6 statements
  5. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 7 statements
  6. Oral Questions The Economy 4 statements
  7. Oral Questions Agriculture and Agri-Food 10 statements
  8. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  9. Oral Questions Public Safety 2 statements
  10. Oral Questions Public Services and Procurement 2 statements
  11. Oral Questions Government Priorities 2 statements
  12. Oral Questions Infrastructure 2 statements
  13. Oral Questions Government Priorities 5 statements
  14. Oral Questions Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship 2 statements
  15. Oral Questions Finance 2 statements
  16. Oral Questions Climate Change 2 statements
  17. Oral Questions Industry 3 statements
  18. Oral Questions Business of the House 2 statements
  19. Government Orders The Budget 16 statements
  20. Oral Questions The Environment 2 statements
  21. Oral Questions Steel and Aluminum Industry 2 statements
  22. Government Orders The Budget 8 statements
  23. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 2 statements
  24. Oral Questions Automotive Industry 10 statements
  25. Oral Questions Public Safety 9 statements
  26. Government Orders The Budget 15 statements
  27. Government Orders The Budget 26 statements
  28. Private Members' Business Stand on Guard Act 12 statements
  29. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  30. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements
  31. Adjournment Proceedings Adjournment Proceedings 4 statements